Emotional parents of teens killed in N.J. hit-and-run vow to "fight like hell" for justice as suspect pleads not guilty
An 18-year-old man pleaded not guilty Monday to charges in the hit-and-run deaths of two 17-year-old New Jersey girls.
Vincent Battiloro is accused of intentionally hitting Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas as they were riding an e-bike in Cranford in September 2025.
Investigators said Battiloro, who was also 17 at the time, fled the scene.
Over the summer, it was determined that Battiloro would be tried as an adult. He faces two counts of first-degree murder.
Monday marked his first in-person court appearance. Battiloro wore a tan jumpsuit in court and said nothing as his attorneys entered the not guilty plea, and suggested he would be leaning on an insanity and diminished capacity defense. Battiloro's attorney also indicated he will seek a change of venue for the trial.
"There have been things that have happened both in the public eye, as well as in the media, since the outset of this case that already give rise to the basis of the motion," said defense attorney Rubin Sinins.
Family members of the victims gathered in the court, then cried and delivered emotional remarks outside. The mothers of the two victims held each other and sobbed moments after coming face-to-face with Battiloro in court. They wore T-shirts with pictures of their daughters.
"One year ago, our daughter Isabella - we called her Bella - and her best friend Maria were taken from all of us. They were 17 years old, about to graduate high school. They were inseparable. The world lost two rays of sunshine that day. Their dreams will never be lived, and nothing will bring our girls back. But we will not let their story end in silence," Mary Salas said. "Justice means the whole truth told in full. It means everyone who failed Isabella ... is held accountable. We will keep their memories alive, and we will fight like hell until they get the justice they deserve."
The grief-stricken mothers say Maria had plans to go into cosmetology. Bella wanted to be a music teacher.
In a joint statement, the mothers said they want justice in what they described as premeditated murders.
A probable cause affidavit says there is dashcam video.
Attorneys for the families say Battiloro had previously stalked the Cranford High School students and want to know if he got special treatment because his dad's a retired police officer and his uncle is a police chief. They claim they've been denied access to police body camera video before the tragic killings.
"We'd like to see some accountability," attorney Brendt Bramnick said. "We are talking about an instance before this ever happened where there are going to be body cams. There are going to be body cameras on the police. This is a year after the accident. Where are the body cams?"
We reached out to Cranford Police but were told nothing is being released because the case is in prosecutors' hands.
Attorneys for the family say they are asking the attorney general's office to investigate the events before the killings.
Battiloro will be back in court on Dec. 14 for a status hearing.
