Watch CBS News

How Far Does Free Speech Reach?

Small business owners and their employees often look at freedom of speech from conflicting angles. The First Amendment to the Constitution protects individuals from government actions that could infringe upon their right to speak their minds. It does not necessarily provide the same protections to employees or owners of a private business. Put simply, the First Amendment is complicated and as such is all too often misunderstood.

Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences

An employee has the right to speak his mind, but freedom of speech does not mean he's protected from the consequences for so doing so, especially if done on a company's website or through its email network. Such platforms are inappropriate platforms from which to criticize a company, its policies, its management or its employees. Every company has a chain of command through which such opinions can be passed or addressed, and in most cases, this means doing so privately to the HR department or immediate supervisor. Employees who post criticisms of their company in public forums should also understand that, while they do indeed by law have the right to do so, that same law does not protect them from whatever consequences they may suffer at work.

Employees have the right to discuss working conditions

The right of free speech covers many "whistleblowers" who reveal discriminatory, unsafe and other illegal actions of their employers. The National Labor Relations Act also protects employees in the private sector who share work-related experiences and situations, including sharing information on salary, benefits and other compensation. Employers, however, can set limits on what employees may reveal about a business — such as trade secrets and other confidential information — and on any speech or action that interferes with the conduct of business, including speech that intimidates, harasses or discriminates against others.

Business owners can say what they want, even if it may lose business

A number of business owners have spoken out on controversial issues in recent years. These range from bakers who will not make a wedding cake with two grooms to CEOs who discourage the hiring of people of a particular ethnic group or political association. Businesses often face the consequences of such actions or policies in the form of bad press, boycotts, loss of sponsors, advertisers or clients, or in cases where they may have infringed upon the rights of others, even legal action.

Consumers, businesses, and the right to "Yelp"

Many businesses have complained or even taken legal steps in reaction to negative reviews posted on Yelp and other websites. In almost every case, the courts have ruled in favor of the consumer. Businesses which have made customers sign contracts that are designed to prevent clients from making negative comments in print or online have, in almost every case, seen those contracts voided by the courts, as they have been deemed actions taken to stifle the rights of others. Unless a business can prove that a consumer or website has malicious intent or has made false statements, there is little they can do to force a retraction, let alone seek compensation for lost business. Liable and slander laws offer some protection, but except in extreme cases, a business's first and best line of defense is to launch a positive public relations campaign, and take actions that encourage satisfied clients and customers to express that satisfaction in the same or other public forums where negative reviews have been published.

This article was written by Mark G. McLaughlin for Small Business Pulse

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.