In the opener of Sunday's split doubleheader, Pete Alonso hit a tying home run off imploding Yankees closer Aroldis Chapman leading off the seventh inning and José Peraza had a go-ahead, two-run double that included interference from a visiting fan in the Bronx in a 10-5 Mets stunner. The Mets also won Saturday's series opener 8-3.
Alonso connected in the late game as well, becoming the first Mets player since Shawn Green on Sept 6, 2006, to homer in both ends of a doubleheader.
With fireworks echoing around jam-packed Yankee Stadium, the Bronx Bombers won for the second time in nine games to get back above .500 at 42-41. They were 10 1/2 games back of the AL East-leading Red Sox before winning the second game. They've only overcome a division deficit that large to finish first once, in 1978.
Urshela has three of the Yankees' eight three-run homers just past the midpoint of the season. New York had 34 three-run shots in 2019.
Yankees reliever Nestor Cortes Jr. made his first start of the season in the nightcap and kept the Mets uncomfortable with his ever-changing delivery. The left-hander was pulled after 3 1/3 innings of quick pitches, sidearm deliveries and variable leg kicks. He allowed only two hits, but Darren O'Day let one of his inherited runners score on Alonso's 15th homer.
Chad Green (3-4) closed with three perfect innings, striking out six in his longest outing since Sept. 8, 2019, vs. Boston, when he also went three innings.
The right-hander finished with an immaculate inning, the second this year by a Yankees pitcher. Michael King also got three strikeouts on nine pitches June 4 against Boston.
Corey Oswalt (1-1) allowed Urshela's homer to the short porch in right field but otherwise held his own in his first start of the season. The right-hander was charged with three runs and four hits over four innings. He walked one and struck out four.
After the NL East-leading Mets roughed up Yankees ace Gerrit Cole in a back-and-forth first game Sunday, Alonso opened the seventh by dropping his barrel on Chapman's 1-2 slider near the bottom of the zone and lofting it into the visitors' bullpen to tie it at 5.
Chapman then plunked Michael Conforto, walked Jeff McNeil and was promptly yanked by manager Aaron Boone.
A few batters later, Peraza ripped a ball off Lucas Luetge that would've hit midway up the left-field wall, but a fan in a Mets jersey reached over to catch the ball with his glove.
Confused players and fans initially had no idea where the ball went. Left fielder Tim Locastro pointed at the fan incredulously, and umpires conferred on the infield before awarding Peraza two bases. The Yankees didn't argue.
"At no point did I realize a fan had caught the ball," Peraza said via translator.
Brandon Nimmo followed with a two-run single and Francisco Lindor added an RBI hit as the Mets piled on.
Jeurys Familia (3-1) pitched a scoreless sixth for the Mets, who also got a solo homer from Dominic Smith.
PLUMMETING IN PINSTRIPES
The Yankees were 41-41 after Game 1, the latest into a season they've been at .500 since they were 56-56 on Aug. 9, 2016. They haven't had a losing record this late since hitting 45-46 on July 17, 2016.
Chapman (5-3) failed to get an out in his first appearance since giving up a tying grand slam in the ninth inning during an 11-8 loss Wednesday to the Los Angeles Angels. The flame-throwing left-hander has a 22.26 ERA in his past nine outings.
It's unclear if Chapman will remain in the closer's role.
"We'll have to talk through that," Boone said.
The Mets chased Cole with one out in the third, his shortest outing since a two-inning stint on Sept. 12, 2016, with Pittsburgh. He was charged with four runs and six hits, tying a season high with three walks. Yankees fans booed as he departed.
Cole has a 5.24 ERA since it became clear in early June that Major League Baseball planned to crack down on pitchers' use of illegal foreign substances. He had a 1.78 ERA prior to that.
Boone denied Cole's and Chapman's struggles were tied to the uptick in enforcement. Cole maintains his pitches are sharp as ever despite measured drops in spin rate on his fastball and slider.
"Our metrics are telling us it's the same stuff," he said, adding: "I felt that I had pretty good stuff today and the ball was moving the way we wanted."
Cole and Chapman were named to the AL All-Star team shortly after the first game.
LIKE OLD NEW YORK
The Yankees sold 42,107 tickets for Sunday night's game after 42,714 paid to see the day game and 40,047 attended Saturday's contest. All three totals are the largest for a crowd at either New York stadium since before the pandemic.
ESPN's Sunday Night Baseball broadcast team called its first in-person game since 2019. Fans shouted at commentator and former Yankees slugger Alex Rodriguez from in front of the broadcast suite. One suggested A-Rod hit cleanup.
Mets: Activated INF Jonathan Villar (strained right calf) from the injured list and started him in Game 2. OF Albert Almora Jr. was optioned to Triple-A. ... RHP Yennsy Diaz was recalled from Triple-A and RHP Sean Reid-Foley was placed on the 10-day IL with right elbow inflammation.
Yankees: LHP Zack Britton (hamstring) will throw at least one more bullpen Tuesday before the team considers activating him.
Mets: Rookie RHP Tylor Megill (0-0, 4.82 ERA) makes his third big league start against Brewers All-Star RHP Brandon Woodruff (7-3, 1.87) on Monday night at Citi Field. Milwaukee's 11-game winning streak ended Sunday with a 2-0 loss in Pittsburgh.
Yankees: RHP Jameson Taillon (3-4, 5.43) faces Mariners LHP Justus Sheffield (5-7, 5.88) on Tuesday night in the opener of a series at Seattle.
(© Copyright 2021 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)
for more features.