Watch CBS News

Former NYPD sergeant sentenced for deadly wrong-way crash in Westchester County

A former NYPD sergeant convicted of being involved in a deadly wrong-way crash on the Taconic State Parkway is on her way to prison.

Investigators said Tiffany Howell, 48, was off-duty and intoxicated when she drove south in the northbound lanes of the parkway in January. She will serve at least four years in prison for killing Manuel Boitel, 61.

"I am truly sorry, and if I could do anything to change what happened that night, I would in a heartbeat," Howell said in court Wednesday. 

Howell pleaded guilty to aggravated vehicular homicide and manslaughter during a plea deal in August. 

Authorities said she got drunk at an NYPD Holy Name Society off-duty party in Greenburgh. Howell crashed head-on into a car driven by Boitel. The attorney general's office said she was going more than 50 mph at the time and caused fatal injuries to Boitel.

Prosecutors said Howell's blood-alcohol content was at least 0.18, which is more than twice the legal limit. She was placed on modified duty by the NYPD after the crash, then suspended without pay 11 days later. 

At sentencing, Boitel's son Eric spoke of anger that a law enforcement officer of all people would act in such a way. 

"As an officer of the law, she knows the damage that drunk driving causes a family. She has seen firsthand the devastation that actions can leave behind. She knows that one reckless decision can take someone's life, tear a family apart and leave loved ones carrying pain for the rest of their lives," Eric Boitel said. "Knowing that he was killed by someone from the very group he looked up to just feels horrible. My family and I will never be the same after the loss of my father."

"I am profoundly sorry for the pain that I've caused the family and friends. I do take full responsibility for my actions. I know I made a terrible decision and I know the consequences are irreversible," Howell said at sentencing. "It's incredibly painful to know that my actions were the complete opposite of the values that I spent my career upholding." 

Howell's apology rang hollow, as far as the Boitel family is concerned. 

"It doesn't feel sincere. It doesn't feel like it's from the heart," Eric Boitel said. 

"It looked to us to be performative, and I still disagree with the sentencing. Four to 12 [years] isn't enough," Marvin Boitel said. 

Because the death of Manuel Boitel involved a police officer, the case was prosecuted by the office of New York State Attorney General Letitia James, which asked for a sentence of six to 18 years.

Judge Ann Bianchi agreed to a sentence of four to 12 years after Howell promised not to appeal her case.

The office of Westchester County District Attorney Susan Cacace had no role in the prosecution.

Boitel was a husband and father of two from Peekskill. He was heading home from working the night shift as a doorman at a Manhattan condominium when he died. 

Defense attorney Andrew Quinn called what happened "tragic beyond words" and out of character for Howell. He described her as a woman of integrity, kindness, generosity and compassion. 

Howell was led away from the courtroom in handcuffs. She'll be eligible for parole in four years. 

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue