Watch CBS News

Minneapolis council votes 9-4 to eliminate safety office; Mayor Frey won't say whether he'll veto

The Minneapolis City Council voted 9-4 to eliminate the Office of Community Safety, including the community safety commissioner position, as part of an ordinance that restructures city government.

The office, created in 2022, supervises the police and fire departments, 911, emergency management and neighborhood safety. It was established in the wake of the civil unrest that followed the killing of George Floyd, designed to improve accountability for police and other first responders while improving coordination between each public safety department.

Council Member Robin Wonsley believes the office ultimately failed in that goal, pointing to repeated issues with police budget management. Wonsley and Council President Elliott Payne said that the city's charter ultimately dictates that the mayor's office is in charge of supervising public safety department heads, arguing that the office has become an ineffective and expensive middleman.

"I don't think taxpayers should be paying 2.1 million dollars for a scheduler," Wonsley said, "we feel very confident that without this administrative bloat present we'll be able to deliver meaningful results that keeps our residents safe."

Mayor Jacob Frey said that his office simply isn't equipped to take on the day-to-day tasks that the office performs, tasks that he believes have been critical in making sure the city adheres to legal public safety requirements that came in response to Floyd's death.

"There's no doubt in my mind that on issues like the settlement agreement, it's going to take a hit," Frey said.

Council Member Jamison Whiting was among the four to vote against the ordinance that eliminates the office. He said that this move will hurt the progress that the city has made in public safety.

"This action that the council took is one of the more reckless policy actions that I saw," Whiting said, "what this essentially does is remove the sole body, the sole department whose only focus is moving forward accountability for our police officers at MPD, Fire and Emergency Management."

Council Member Wonsley said that the council is continuing to fund and support other non-policing initiatives, telling WCCO that residents will not notice a difference in emergency services or options.

"All those services remain tomorrow and they will remain in place after the Office of Community Safety is eliminated," Wonsley said, "the only change is they report directly to the mayor. Which is what our charter requires and what our government structure requires."

Wonsley and other council members also argued this is a cost-saving measure. The ordinance also eliminates the Performance Management and Innovation Department and the Racial Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging Department. It adds to the Neighborhood and Community Relations Department's work advancing racial equity and inclusivity in city services and programs, and it codifies the department's existing work supporting immigrant communities. All told, Wonsley said that this will save $3.8 million.

Mayor Frey disagrees on the financials as well. He said his office estimates that this ordinance, when combined with other measures approved by the council on Thursday, will actually add approximately $3 million to the city's spending.

He said that if this was purely a financial measure, he'd be willing to cut half of the office's staff, which amounts to about four people. Wonsley said that the time for that kind of compromise has passed.

The mayor did not definitively say if he'd veto Thursday's ordinance, but if the nine council members who voted together on this remain unified, that would be enough to override a veto attempt.

What's still somewhat unclear is what happens to the office now. Wonsley said that the department will operate business as usual until January, while Whiting said that the office itself is now functionally gone. However, the eight employees who make up the department still have their jobs.

Toddrick Barnette, a former Hennepin County chief judge, was nominated by Frey and sworn in as commissioner in October 2023. He succeeded Cedric Alexander, the first person to hold the job.

The council voted 7-6 on April 9 against reappointing Barnette after Frey nominated him for another term. Payne said Barnette had been "far too absent and often disconnected from the role." Other council members who voted no argued he failed to control overspending and poorly managed the city's violence interruptor program. Frey vetoed the decision. A city spokesperson said no one had vetoed a cabinet appointee before, at least since the current city government structure was established in 2013.

The council voted 7-6 on April 20 to override the veto, falling short of the nine votes needed. The outcome meant the council's rejection did not stand, but Barnette did not receive a new permanent term either.

Barnette has since served as interim commissioner. A city spokesperson said in August that he will leave at the end of the year while a search for a permanent commissioner moves forward.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue