Man Files Claim Against NYPD After Harlem Shootout
NEW YORK (AP/WCBS 880) -- A bystander who took a bullet to the thigh during a police shootout with another man at a block party filed a preview of a $20 million lawsuit Wednesday as authorities continued investigating the chaotic chain of events that left one man dead, another with 21 bullet wounds and two officers hurt.
It was not yet clear whether police or someone else fired the bullet still in Larry Garlick's leg. But his lawyer said the New York Police Department should be held responsible for what he called a flawed response to a Harlem street fight that spiraled into a fusillade.
Who fired the bullet is "really irrelevant because but not for the improper handling of the entire situation by the NYPD, my client would not have a bullet lodged in his thigh," attorney Bruce Baron said after filing a pre-lawsuit document called a notice of claim.
City lawyers said they would review the claim.
Garlick, who lives in the Bronx, was visiting with relatives when the violence unfolded around 3 a.m. Sunday, Baron said.
As an influx of police arrived to disperse a crowd that had lingered hours after the party's scheduled end, two men with a history of bad blood between them -- Angel Alvarez, 23, and Luis Soto, 21 -- started fighting, police said.
A witness told police Soto pulled a gun from his waistband, and the men struggled over it. One or two shots rang out -- it's unclear who fired them or whether both men had guns -- then Alvarez pulled away and fired more shots toward a uniformed officer, police said.
That officer fired back two rounds -- one hit a plainclothes officer in his bullet-resistant vest -- and three plainclothes officers nearby fired 44 times, according to police.
By the time the shooting was over, Soto was dead, with the fatal bullet likely fired by police, according to autopsy and ballistics reports. Alvarez had 21 gunshot wounds, though it's unclear how many were made by police bullets. He was hospitalized in stable condition.
Another officer was grazed by a bullet, and Garlick and two other bystanders also were hit.
No one has been charged with any crime in the shooting. The officers involved were placed on desk duty while the investigation continues.
Garlick, a 38-year-old Salvation Army worker, has been released from a hospital but faces multiple surgeries, Baron said.
Garlick's claim accuses the NYPD of negligence. Among other things, it says officers weren't adequately trained on so-called "contagious" or "reflexive" shooting -- firing an excessive number of rounds in a chain reaction.
The NYPD enhanced officers' training for such scenarios after an unarmed man, Sean Bell, died in a barrage of 50 police bullets on his wedding day in November 2006.
(Copyright 2010 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)