Elmo Restaurant, staple in NYC's LGBTQ+ community, closes after 25 years
Elmo Restaurant, which New York City patrons revered as an LGBTQ+ community space that just happened to sell food and drinks, closes Friday after 25 years.
Customers went to the iconic restaurant nestled in the heart of Chelsea for one last meal before it officially shut its doors after a quarter century.
Hugs, laughs, selfies
There were bittersweet cheers to Elmo's unforgettable 25-year run, complete with hugs, laughs and, of course, selfies, among the last ever to be taken inside its walls
Kevin Gammariello and his friends knew they had to grab lunch on its last day in business.
"This place is the center of our lives," Gammariello said.
Elmo is short for El Morocco, an iconic club that closed in the '50s. It's been considered the linchpin of the city's LGBTQ+ community.
"When so many of us were young adults and figuring out who we were in the city, and this was one of those cool, relaxed places," Steven Gottlieb said.
Why Elmo Restaurant decided to close
Owner Rob Pontarelli announced Elmo's closure less than two weeks ago when he said the building was sold to build residential spaces.
Since then, Pontarelli said he's received thousands of messages from across the world.
"The second this was announced, you couldn't get a reservation for dinner. It was like instantly sold out," Robert Accordino said.
Many also remembered LGBTQ-friendly Claire's Restaurant, which operated in the same space decades ago, saying Elmo carried on the legacy.
"I'll never forget either one of them. They had different flavors," David Larkin said.
Angelo Benevento said his late partner Joseph, who died of AIDS 30 years ago, "would've loved this [place]." He said what the community built over the past few decades made spaces like Elmo soar in popularity.
"When I see this, it's nice. Without the fight that we did, this would not happen," Benevento said.
Patrons said Elmo's legacy will forever be woven into the tight-knit fabric of Chelsea's rich LGBTQ+ history.
