Watch CBS News

Waitress Accused Of Scamming Elderly Woman Out Of Nearly $500,000

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork) -- A waitress who befriended a widow has gone from server to suspect – now standing accused of heartlessly taking the elderly woman for pretty much every penny she had.

As CBS2's Tony Aiello reported Tuesday, Alicia Legall, 46, posted images of fur coats and a fistful of cash to Facebook. She is accused of living the high life after allegedly bilking an 84-year-old Brooklyn widow out of almost $500,000.

"What happened here is an outrage," said Acting Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez. "(S)he stole her life savings, opened lines of credit -- really took advantage of this widow."

Gonzalez said it started in 2004, when Legall worked at the Arch Diner as a waitress.

She allegedly met the recently-widowed victim and spent years building trust, eventually gaining access to her money.

According to the indictment, Legall forged the victim's signature to cash 75 checks totaling $200,000, and used her credit cards on a $270,000 spending spree.

Some of the proceeds were allegedly sent to racetracks, where Legall bet heavily.

"Very scary; terrible," one woman said. "Have to be very careful and protect ourselves."

"No one should be treated like that," said the victim's neighbor Joey Karr. "Honestly, I would go after who would ever do that to my family."

DA Gonzalez said it is vital to stay in touch with older relatives and monitor who has access to their assets.

"Too often, we see victims who come forward who are being isolated and are turning to somebody who they befriended, and the person starts stealing from them," Gonzalez said.

An interesting thing happened at Legall's arraignment, Aiello reported. The DA asked for $1 million bail, but the judge set it at $2.5 million -- apparently concerned she is a flight risk who's been living recently with a much older widower.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.