Watch CBS News

Dottino: Game Balls And Gassers From The Giants' Disastrous Defeat

By Paul Dottino
» More Columns

Pick out any stat you'd like from the Giants' embarrassing 38-0 loss to the Carolina Panthers. This game was ugly and, after an 0-3 start, it's apparent that the team's problems are worse than the coaching staff might have thought. The bottom line is simple -- the Giants are getting beaten in the trenches on both sides of the ball.

The Giants have not been 0-3 since 1996. They have been blanked just three times since the start of the 1997 season -- twice by Carolina. (Remember the playoff debacle after the 2005 season?) This also represented their worst shutout since a 35-0 whitewash by Dallas to open the 1995 season.

Offense: WR Rueben Randle -- He caught only two passes for 40 yards, but showed bravery and heart when he held on for a 24-yard gain after the game was long out of reach in the fourth quarter. Randle took a powerful hit to the ribs from CB Josh Norman and was down for a few minutes. But Randle made the play and paid for it

Defense: S Ryan Mundy -- He continues to prove that he's a solid tackler (team-leading nine stops) and does not get caught in blown coverage.

Special Teams: P Steve Weatherford -- He rebounded well from his worst game as a Giant. He punted six times for a 40.8 avg., including a solid 38.8 net avg. and two kicks inside the 20.

Offense: LT William Beatty -- He can run a few extra rounds after the rest of the offensive line is done with their sprints. He got burned for two sacks during the Panthers' six-sack first half. His most critical play was the holding penalty (grabbed DE Greg Hardy) that wiped out RB David Wilson's 17-yard TD sprint around the left edge. The run would have made it 7-6, pending the extra point, with 13:46 left in the first half.

Defense: CB Aaron Ross -- He played well in the first half, and even had an interception deep in Carolina territory that led to a failed scoring drive. But he then got turned around on WR Brandon LaFell's 20-yard TD grab on a go-route in the third quarter. Ross also was burned for a 47-yard TD by WR Ted Ginn Jr. on a post-route in the fourth.

Special teams: PK Josh Brown -- He capped the drive that should have included Wilson's TD by pulling a 38-yard field-goal try far to the left. The miss provided a big momentum shift in the game. Carolina's Graham Gano finished the ensuing drive with a 53-yard FG for a 10-0 edge.

You May Also Be Interested In These Stories

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.