St. Paul school board approves English learner teacher early retirement plan after pushback on proposed cuts
The St. Paul Board of Education has approved a revised plan to get out of a multi-million-dollar hole after significant pushback from parents and teachers.
The board's original proposal called for cutting up to 18 English learner teachers across the district. On Friday, the group voted 6-1 to approve a plan that offers an early retirement package for up to 12 English learner teachers and includes keeping more than 10 vacant positions unfilled.
"We believe that asking for early retirements and having our members who are ready to step out of the classroom and do what they want to do next in their lives is a better option than taking layoffs and terminations mid-year," Erica Schatzlein, St. Paul Federation of Educators' lead negotiator, said on Friday. "We think that this is a better path, and this is a really exciting outcome now."
The approved measure could save nearly $2.3 million, and district leaders say other budget adjustments could lead to a total savings of around $5.3 million.
The district says it's losing more than 500 English learner students this school year, which is 542 fewer than projected. That's nearly $5 million in lost funding.
District leaders have pointed in part to Operation Metro Surge and the federal immigration crackdown in the Twin Cities.
"We heard from landlords, we heard from neighbors, they're not here. They moved away. Sometimes we did hear they're deported, sometimes we did hear they self-deported," Superintendent Dr. Stacie Stanley said. "What we do know is that we have never seen a significant drop of almost 600 immigrant students in our time in the past decade."
Stanley and Schatzlein both said they are confident that enough teachers will choose to take the retirement option. Schatzlein said that the back-up option would be that five probationary EL teachers are laid off and become long-term substitutes for the district.
Still, some school board members expressed concerns about how viable the plan is or what the long-term future looks like. Brandon Lowe was the lone "no" vote on the resolution.
"We are taking ourselves so close to the edge of the fund balance, and we're doing so without certainty that we are going to get all of the savings that we see here," Lowe said.
Stanley said that her focus will be on recruitment and promoting Saint Paul Public Schools as the best option for children and families in the area. Part of what made Friday's approved plan possible, she said, was the fact that they were able to identify and enroll 96 new students from neighboring districts. Stanley said that the district contracted with Caissa K12, a company that markets itself as "public school enrollment specialists" that have the time to make the phone calls that district staff may not.
"We're excited about that because that was almost $1 million. Without that, that would have made a significant difference in the number of reductions we needed to do," Stanley said.
Schatzlein said that she believes the state of Minnesota or even the federal government will need to help with additional funding or education policies to keep the public school system afloat.
In June, the board approved an $814.5 million budget for the 2026-27 school year, which came after the district faced a $51.5 million deficit ahead of the 2025-26 school year.