Watch CBS News

Watchdog secures settlement with Pine Island over Google data center concerns

As data centers continue stirring controversy across the United States, a nonprofit has secured a settlement around a nearly 500-acre project in the small southeastern Minnesota town of Pine Island.

Project Skyway is the proposed three-story Google data center in the Goodhue County town, located about 20 miles northwest of Rochester. The nonprofit Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy, which filed the lawsuit, says the city's environmental review of the project wasn't up to par. 

Pine Island City Council's approval of the settlement Wednesday night will make this project the first in the state to be reviewed by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency.

The center's lawsuit alleges the company didn't disclose info about its scale, and the water and energy it plans to use. Kathryn Hoffman, the center's CEO, told WCCO in an interview Thursday they're looking for simple transparency at this rate, and are happy about the oversight the state will now have.  

pine.jpg
Pine Island, Minnesota. WCCO

"A developer, Ryan Companies, has proposed to build a hyperscale, or AI data center. It houses computing equipment that's used for new AI technology," Hoffman said. "We're not even at the point where we can say how much water you're going to use and what that means."

Google and Ryan Companies say in statements that they're pleased with the resolution. Pine Island Mayor Brandi Veith Staloch says she believes this will help ensure the project moves forward responsibly.

WCCO spoke with a resident who didn't want to be identified. He said he didn't mind the project, though many signs against it can be seen across the city.

MPCA gave this statement to WCCO: "The MPCA had previously notified the project proposer this project requires an Environmental Assessment Worksheet, as the project trips a mandatory category in Minnesota Rules (Minn R 4410.4300 Subp 3 A). More information about the process is outlined on our environmental review page. The MPCA is still reviewing the terms of the settlement and if that may change the normal process."

Earlier this month, Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison expressed his concerns that Project Skyway could end up costing Minnesota Xcel Energy customers billions of dollars.

Ellison also claimed Echo Zone, LLC, the Google subsidiary behind the project, and Xcel "redacted almost all of the dollar amounts of these potential impacts" and the two haven't "provided specific explanations for some of its redactions."

In a statement to WCCO, an Xcel spokesperson called Ellison's comments "inconsistent with the facts in the docket," and said Google will "pay their own way."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue