Parents of Alex Pretti, slain by Border Patrol in Minneapolis, call on DOJ to resume evidence sharing
The parents of Alex Pretti, who U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers shot and killed in Minneapolis nine months ago amid Operation Metro Surge, called for the U.S. Department of Justice on Tuesday to resume sharing evidence in the investigation into his killing.
Thirty-seven-year-old Alex Pretti, who was an ICU nurse, was the second person to be fatally shot by federal agents in a matter of weeks during the immigration crackdown in Minnesota.
Michael and Susan Pretti held their first press conference Tuesday morning alongside their attorney, Steven Schleicher. Susan Pretti said her son "understood right from wrong, and did not tolerate bullies."
"The federal government went on TV and lied about Alex. They tried to slander his memory to cover up their crime. Not only was it wrong, it was shameful, unfair, unacceptable," said Susan Pretti. "We want to clear our son's name. We want the world to understand who Alex really was. We want our son's killers brought to justice once and for all."
Michael Pretti called the lack of federal cooperation "baffling," "disappointing" and "reprehensible."
"Imagine that your child was killed because of the actions of the government, federal government. Imagine learning that your child had been murdered by watching it on TV. No one from the government called you, called us that day. They didn't call us the next day, nor the next, nor the next 275 days. We have not heard anything from the federal government," said Michael Pretti.
He said while he understands "the wheels of justice move slowly," Michael Pretti said he feels Dan Rosen, the U.S. Attorney for the District of Minnesota, and U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche have offered them nothing but "cruelty."
"At every turn they have ignored us, misled us and shielded Alex's killers," said Michael Pretti. "This is not normal. This is not justice. It is morally wrong. My message to Dan Rosen and attorney Todd Blanche: look in your heart and do what is right. Share the evidence now so prosecutors can follow the facts and hold these men accountable. Do your job and stop shielding Alex's killers."
Schleicher, a former federal prosecutor himself, said he's never seen "a case conducted like this" in his 20-plus years in law.
"Why are they fighting the state in court? Why is it necessary for Hennepin County authorities to have to file a lawsuit? To get evidence that they should be entitled to review?" Schleicher said. "We're hopeful that the federal government will listen, that they will stop this, that they will stop fighting the state in court."
The Hennepin County Attorney's Office released a statement to WCCO following the press conference.
"The federal government continues to obstruct our investigation into Alex Pretti's killing. That's why we continue to pursue our lawsuit in federal court to access the evidence that is being wrongly withheld," the statement said. "We have repeatedly asked for the cooperation to resume. Those requests have fallen on deaf ears. Alex Pretti died at the hands of federal agents and their bosses continue to hide evidence. It's disgusting behavior that reflects how little they care for the American people, who deserve transparency about a fatal shooting by a federal agent."
"We do not want to be on TV"
The Prettis, who live in Colorado, also said they are in awe of the outpouring of support in the aftermath of their son's killing, as well as the tireless work by those keeping watch over his memorial off East 26th Street and Nicollet Avenue.
"We've received over 2,000 cards and letters, we've read every single word, we've kept every single one of those cards. We can't thank everybody individually, but for those people who are seeing this and have sent something to us, thank you from the bottom of our hearts. Thank you. It makes a difference. It helps," said Michael Pretti.
The Prettis and Schleicher also made it clear that their public appeal Tuesday was not connected to next week's midterm elections.
"Mike and I are not asking for any special treatment. We do not want to be on TV. We are not political activists nor do we want to become political activists," said Susan Pretti. "All we want is justice for Alex. We are here today to simply request that the federal government treat us with dignity and respect that our son deserves."
"We wish Alex was alive. We wish we were simply in Minneapolis to visit with Alex, for he and I had to chat about cars, hiking, biking or anything that came to our mind," said Michael Pretti. "This administration has taken that away from us forever."
Footage of Pretti's killing contrasts with previous DOJ accounts
Cellphone footage from bystanders on Jan. 24 captured Alex Pretti confronting a federal officer who had pushed a woman into a snowbank. The officer then uses a chemical irritant on him. Multiple federal officers surround him and take him to the ground. While he's on the ground, an agent wearing gray appears to take something from his waist.
In another video obtained by CBS News, that officer can clearly be seen removing the gun from Alex Pretti's waistband. The agent is holding that gun and turning away when the first shot is fired just one second later. That is then followed by at least 10 more audible shots.
It is not clear from the videos how many officers fired shots, but a report to Congress obtained by CBS News on Jan. 27 said two Border Patrol agents fired their weapons during the deadly incident.
Then-Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem faced heavy scrutiny over her reaction to Alex Pretti's killing. Hours after the shooting, Noem alleged he had "approached" Border Patrol agents with a gun and "violently resisted" after officers tried to disarm him, and Greg Bovino — then commander at large of the Border Patrol — accused Alex Pretti of trying to "massacre law enforcement." Noem later stepped down from her role, and Bovino was demoted. He went on to retire in March.
Then-Minneapolis Police Chief Brian O'Hara said Alex Pretti was a lawful gun owner with a permit to carry.
The DOJ's off-and-on evidence sharing
Federal investigators initially refused to share evidence with Minnesota state investigators in the three federal immigration officer shootings, prompting state and county officials to sue the federal government. In July, Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty announced that evidence sharing had begun, but officials said it stopped shortly after that announcement.
In the Alex Pretti case, Drew Evans, superintendent of the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, said the state has not received the firearms used by the officers who shot him, a firearm that was taken from Alex Pretti before he was shot, the officers' cellphones, projectiles and casings, or a recording of a statement from one of those officers.
WCCO has reached out to the justice department for comment, but sources familiar with the investigation say almost all evidence has been shared. The source also says they have spoken with the Pretti family attorney. They believe the sharing will resume soon, and they thank everyone for their patience.
Renee Good, 37, was shot and killed by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent in her car in Minneapolis on Jan. 7, just weeks before Alex Pretti's killing.
Julio Cesar Sosa-Celis, a Venezuelan national, was shot in the leg by a federal immigration agent Jan. 14. Federal prosecutors charged him with assaulting the agent, then dropped the case in February. The agent, Christian Castro, is accused of lying about the shooting and faces both state and federal charges.
