KCBS News Anchor Stan Bunger (who along with KCBS Sports Anchor Steve Bitker are the on-air duo known as KCBS Sports Fans) offers his unique sports analysis.
I hate to say I Told You So, but I'm going to do it anyway: video replay is destroying pro sports.
Go ahead, tell me I'm wrong. Tell me how important it is to "get the call right." Tell me how we can't have a situation where TV replays prove the officials got it wrong, but we allow a bad call to stand. Tell me how we can't have the technology but refuse to use it.
And I have a two-word answer: Dez Bryant.
Some will argue that it's just the NFL's impenetrable rule defining what constitutes a catch that needs to be fixed. But it's really deeper than that, because no matter how you re-write the rule, there will always be a gray area, a region of doubt, a place where judgment is required.
I'll challenge replay advocates this way: if you're so sure that video replay is the way to go, why isn't every call (including balls and strikes in baseball and pass interference in football) reviewable?
You already know the answer: because it would make a mockery of the game.
I have news for you. We're most of the way there already.
Commentary: Instant Replay Is Ruining Pro Sports
/ CBS San Francisco
KCBS News Anchor Stan Bunger (who along with KCBS Sports Anchor Steve Bitker are the on-air duo known as KCBS Sports Fans) offers his unique sports analysis.
I hate to say I Told You So, but I'm going to do it anyway: video replay is destroying pro sports.
Go ahead, tell me I'm wrong. Tell me how important it is to "get the call right." Tell me how we can't have a situation where TV replays prove the officials got it wrong, but we allow a bad call to stand. Tell me how we can't have the technology but refuse to use it.
And I have a two-word answer: Dez Bryant.
Some will argue that it's just the NFL's impenetrable rule defining what constitutes a catch that needs to be fixed. But it's really deeper than that, because no matter how you re-write the rule, there will always be a gray area, a region of doubt, a place where judgment is required.
I'll challenge replay advocates this way: if you're so sure that video replay is the way to go, why isn't every call (including balls and strikes in baseball and pass interference in football) reviewable?
You already know the answer: because it would make a mockery of the game.
I have news for you. We're most of the way there already.
In:
Featured Local Savings
CBS News Bay Area
Eagles tailgaters rally against new parking restrictions
Repeated flooding has Washington County business considering a move
Speculation swirls on severity of Giants QB Jaxson Dart's injury
A broken powered wheelchair left him stranded. Getting help is a bigger problem.
Hickenlooper, county officials call on ICE to release info on TB reports
Lynn police investigate teen takeover at McDonald's, mayor "deeply concerned"
Pittsburgh doctor says amyloidosis is still underdiagnosed
Broncos LB Que Robinson explains why he gave a Mile High salute