Watch CBS News

Rutgers Stands By New AD Julie Hermann Despite Abuse Allegations

NEWARK, N.J. (CBSNewYork/AP) — Rutgers is standing by its incoming athletic director despite allegations she humiliated and verbally abused players during her coaching days, with the embattled president of the prominent university saying he is looking forward to her first day on the job.

CBS 2's Janelle Burrell exclusively spoke with a student athlete who was on the committee that hired Julie Hermann.

"I think she's gonna do a great job," Rutgers tennis player Stefania Basala told Burrell. "And I think people need to have a little faith in the system."

The newly resurfaced allegations are the latest in a series of difficulties for the school, which lost its previous men's basketball coach and chief athletic executive to an abuse scandal, and then had to acknowledge its new men's coach had not graduated from Rutgers after it previously said he did.

Hermann officially takes over the athletic department on June 17, and on Monday she said she plans to be in the position on that date. And the university is standing behind her.

"I never considered withdrawing because I feel very qualified to lead Rutgers into the future and into the transition into the Big Ten (Conference)," Hermann said during a conference call in response to a report in the Star-Ledger of Newark. "And I do feel the support of the Rutgers community."

Star-Ledger's Craig Wolff

Hermann is at the center of a firestorm after allegations have re-emerged of severe verbal abuse from her former volleyball players who she coached at the University of Tennessee in 1996.

But Basala said she is standing by the new AD.

"If what they are saying is true, it's harsh. Also keep in mind that it was in a different time era where things like that happen," Basala exclusively told Burrell.

Basala was among the group of 26 people given the task of selecting the person to rebuild the reputation of Rutgers Athletics after men's basketball coach Mike Rice was forced to step down when video surfaced of him physically and verbally attacking his players.

Hermann's ex-players contend her approach was equally harsh.

"It wasn't about the game. It was about attacking our character," Kim Obiala said.

In 1997, Hermann was also the at the center of a discrimination lawsuit for allegedly threatening to fire her former assistant coach if she got pregnant.

A videotape from assistant coach Ginger Hineline's wedding was posted on the Star-Ledger's website.

"I don't want you to come back in February with any surprises," Hermann can be heard saying.

Hineline won a $150,000 settlement after claiming she was discouraged by Hermann from getting pregnant.

Basala said the search committee was aware of the lawsuit and the settlement.

The student athlete added she sees Hermann as a strong leader who can help turn the embattled program around and noted the former volleyball player's claims are just accusations.

"We don't even know if it necessarily happened, honestly. It's their words against hers," Basala told Burrell.

President Robert Barchi said in a statement that the university looks forward to her running the athletic department. He added that she was the best of the 63 candidates interviewed for the job of succeeding Tim Pernetti.

"Rutgers was deliberative at every stage of this process," Barchi said. "Over the course of the search, Julie's record established her as a proven leader in athletics administration with a strong commitment to academic success as well as athletic excellence, and a strong commitment to the well-being of student athletes.

Despite the Star-Ledger report, Barchi said Hermann's entire career is stellar.

"We remain confident that we have selected an individual who will work in the best interests of all of our student athletes, our athletics teams, and the university."

Speaking to four reporters on a conference call in which each participant was allowed two questions, Hermann denied having knowledge of a letter written by the 15 players on Tennessee's volleyball team. She said her former boss never heard of it and she never heard her former players make the allegation.

Rutgers officials have talked to her about it in recent days, she said.

Hermann acknowledged she was an intense coach and may have made a few mistakes handling her team. The 49-year-old administrator said she has matured and believes she is qualified to lead the scandal-marred Rutgers program.

"Am I an intense coach? I'm absolutely an intense coach as many coaches are," she said. "But there is a big canyon between being super-intense and abuse. And this was not an abusive environment for these women.''

It was Hermann's first comments since the Star-Ledger's story on Sunday revealed that the Tennessee volleyball team in 1996 sent a letter to the school in which the players said Hermann called them "whores, alcoholics and learning disabled."

Hermann left the following year to work with the United States national volleyball team.

"As I recall, Julie Hermann did not continue as our head coach only due to a lack of significant improvement in her final season overall record with the Lady Vol volleyball program," former Tennessee athletic administrator Debby Jennings wrote in a message to the AP.

Jennings filed a federal lawsuit against the University of Tennessee last September alleging age and sex discrimination led to her forced retirement at the age of 57 in May 2012.

In the past two days, state lawmakers have criticized Hermann's hire and Gov. Chris Christie has said he will speak with school officials about the report. Barring a resignation, only the university's board of governors can withdraw Hermann's appointment.

The governor appoints six of the board's 11 voting members and can wield pressure through a variety of ways, perhaps by threatening to cut school funding or refusing to renominate a board member who doesn't support his view.

With President Barack Obama scheduled to tour the New Jersey shore Tuesday to see the rebuilding after Hurricane Sandy, it is unlikely Christie will turn his attention to Rutgers until Wednesday.

Former New Jersey Gov. and current State Sen. Richard Codey was furious with the latest controversy at Rutgers, saying officials made Pernetti the scapegoat after video of men's basketball coach Mike Rice physically and verbally abusing his players during his three-year tenure came to light in early April.

Rice, who initially had been suspended, fined and ordered to undergo anger management counseling, was fired by Barchi the day after the video was broadcast. Pernetti was forced to resign two days later.

"His successor is someone who is an obvious liar, a flat-out liar," Codey said in a telephone interview with the AP on Monday night. "She shouldn't be the AD anywhere, whether it's Rutgers or anywhere else. She should stay in Louisville and not come back to the state, and Barchi should go to Louisville himself because he is not a leader. It's dumb and dumber."

Hermann believes she can be an effective leader at Rutgers, which has also had several other key officials resign. And after hiring former Scarlet Knights star Eddie Jordan to replace Rice, the university mistakenly called him a graduate when he had never finished his degree.

"All of my life has prepared me to lead this organization," said Hermann, who would be the first woman to serve as Rutgers' athletic director and only the third female AD at the 124 schools playing at college football's top tier.

"Whatever mistakes you make as a young person, you've got to learn from them and go and grow," she added. "It is my intent to go to Rutgers with this vast experience of super highs and super lows and lead what I hope is an outstanding team into the Big Ten."

Other comments from the 10-minute call included:

— Hermann said the company that vetted her for Rutgers did ask about a lawsuit filed by one of her assistant coaches over a job termination.

— Hermann believes she can raise funds despite what has happened.

— Hermann denied the name calling, specifically when asked about calling the players "whores."

"That's not part of my vocabulary. ... Was I aware that there were players that were unhappy? I was aware of that at the end of the season and I was unhappy."

You May Also Be Interested In These Stories

(TM and © Copyright 2013 CBS Radio Inc. and its relevant subsidiaries. CBS RADIO and EYE Logo TM and Copyright 2013 CBS Broadcasting Inc. Used under license. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.