Watch CBS News

City Leaders Defy White House Threat On 'Sanctuary Cities' Policies

NEW YORK (CBSNewYork/AP) -- Ignoring fresh threats from the White House, city leaders across the U.S. are vowing to intensify their fight against President Donald Trump's promised crackdown on so-called "sanctuary cities'' despite the financial risks.

"We are going to become this administration's worst nightmare,'' New York City Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito said Monday during a gathering of municipal officials from urban centers such as San Francisco, Seattle, Denver, Chicago and Philadelphia.

As is the case in several sanctuary cities, they promised to continue blocking cooperation between city police departments and federal immigration authorities. They also vowed to prevent federal agents from accessing their schools and school records, and they openly contemplated employing cities' rarely-used oversight and subpoena powers to investigate federal immigration practices.

"Really sad that the security of our city, the security of our country will be put at stake to just meet a campaign promise to a dwindling base," Mark-Viverito said.

The defiance that filled the New York City conference clashed with pointed warnings from the White House's West Wing, where Attorney General Jeff Sessions issued a dire warning to urban leaders who embrace policies that help protect immigrants in the country illegally from deportation.

"When cities and states refuse to help enforce immigration laws, our nation is less safe," Sessions said, adding that such policies violate federal law.

He said the Trump White House could withhold or "claw back'' funding from any city that "willfully violates'' immigration law.

Sessions said the Justice Department would require cities seeking some of the $4.1 billion available in grant money to verify they are in compliance with a section of federal law that allows information sharing with immigration officials.

"I strongly urge our nation's states and cities and counties to consider carefully the harm they are doing to their citizens by refusing to enforce our immigration laws, and to rethink these policies,'' he charged.

New York City stands to lose millions of dollars. An example of a recent grant that could be affected is more than a half-million dollars for local efforts to combat counterfeit goods and movies.

Mayor Bill de Blasio is promising the city will head to court to fight the administration's move.

In New Jersey, Newark Mayor Ras Baraka said he also plans to join other sanctuary cities in taking legal action against a "misguided policy."

"It is highly ironic that the Attorney General claims that withholding law enforcement funds will make sanctuary cities safer when the opposite is true," Baraka said in a statement. "Taking away desperately needed aid for hiring more police officers, providing up-to-date technology to reduce crime, and encouraging initiatives to build trust and transparency between police and the citizens they are sworn to protect is sure to make cities more dangerous."

The debate highlighted the nation's increasingly polarized view of immigration.

Trump won the presidency by appealing to white working-class voters in a campaign that regularly highlighted violent crimes committed by immigrants in the country illegally. Sessions drew from the same playbook at the White House podium on Monday, citing two recent murders committed by immigrants released by local authorities even though they were wanted by federal agents.

City leaders insisted such examples are the exception, not the rule. Philadelphia City Council member Helen Gym said immigrants in the country illegally are part of the "fabric of America.''

"It's not like immigrants are dangerous. They're actually the ones in the most danger,'' Gym said, citing labor and housing practices that discriminate against immigrants.

Indeed, city officials on Monday shared stories of immigrants in their communities seized by federal immigration agents at their children's schools and at courthouses as they appeared as victims of other crimes. Gym said some landlords have used Trump's hardline immigration rhetoric to expel immigrant tenants.

There are an estimated 11 million immigrants living in the country illegally. There is no evidence that crime rates among immigrants are higher than native-born Americans.

Trump has made illegal immigration a priority.

He issued an executive order in January that directs the Secretary of Homeland Security to publish a weekly list of "criminal actions committed by aliens.'' The administration last week reported more than 200 cases of immigrants recently released from local jails before federal agents could intervene.

In a statement, New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman said he won't stop fighting "Trump's un-American immigration policies."

"President Trump lacks the Constitutional authority to broadly cut off funding to states and cities just because they have lawfully acted to protect immigrant families," Schneiderman said. "Public safety depends on trust between law enforcement and those they bravely serve; yet, again and again, President Trump's draconian policies only serve to undercut that trust."

Lourdes Rosado, who leads the New York attorney general's civil rights bureau, insists that municipalities have legal standing to resist what she described as immigration overreach by the new White House.

"Sessions makes it sound as if we're breaking the law. But the point is, it's voluntary whether or not to cooperate,'' Rosado said, acknowledging that states and cities may have to resolve the issue in court. "Will they come after you? Maybe.''

(© Copyright 2017 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. The Associated Press contributed to this report.)

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.