Watch CBS News

North Miami candidate reinstated as others fight to get back on ballot days before election

A judge reinstated North Miami District 3 City Council candidate Jobans Jules to the ballot Friday, reversing a decision that had disqualified him just one day earlier, as several other candidates continue fighting to remain in their races ahead of Tuesday's election.

"The court vacates the October 29 non-final order," the judge said during Friday afternoon's hearing.

But Jules is not the only candidate whose eligibility has been challenged.

North Miami Mayor Alix Desulme is listed as disqualified from seeking reelection on the city's website. Desulme said his disqualification stemmed from paying his qualifying fees with a cashier's check funded by his campaign account rather than a campaign account check bearing his treasurer's signature.

The mayor disputed earlier reports that he had attempted to pay the fees using his personal bank account.

Desulme's disqualification followed a civil lawsuit filed by his opponent, George Morgan, challenging the payment of his qualifying fees.

The mayor's disqualification followed a civil lawsuit filed by his opponent, George Morgan, challenging how Desulme paid his qualifying fees.

On Friday, dozens of Desulme's supporters gathered at Katz Restaurant in North Miami, calling for Morgan to also be disqualified and demanding a special election.

North Miami election thrown into uncertainty as candidates are disqualified 02:41

Supporters argued that Morgan should face disqualification because he allegedly paid 80 cents less than the required amount in campaign qualifying fees. The allegation has not been independently established.

Desulme said his attorney sent a letter to the North Miami city clerk requesting Morgan's disqualification but has not received a response.

"Yes, absolutely. The clerk holds the power as the clerk to qualify, disqualify candidates," Desulme said when asked whether the clerk had the authority to disqualify Morgan.

In the District 2 City Council race, candidates Hector Medina and Laury Vanessa Metayer are also listed as disqualified. A judge removed Medina from the ballot because his campaign treasurer had not signed his campaign qualifying check.

"Candidates are gonna take advantage of any loophole and anything in the law they can find in their competitors to kick them off the ballot," North Miami voter Eileen Bicaba said.

"Candidates should not be disqualified based on technicalities, but it is the law and we have to uphold the law," she added.

Disqualified candidates challenge decisions in court

Several lawsuits are still making their way through the courts, including legal challenges from disqualified candidates seeking to be reinstated. Desulme is among those fighting to get back on the ballot.

The last-minute legal battles have frustrated some North Miami voters, who say the uncertainty is affecting their decisions about when to cast their ballots.

"I'm disappointed that it's come down to three days before the election before this has come to a head," voter Laurie Landgrebe said.

Landgrebe said she has decided to wait until Election Day rather than vote early because she wants to be certain her preferred candidate remains eligible.

"I am waiting until Election Day to vote, cause I want to know that my vote counts and that the candidate that I elect is in the running," she said.

What happens to votes for disqualified candidates?

A spokesperson for the Miami-Dade County Supervisor of Elections Office said disqualified candidates still appear on printed ballots because the ballots were produced before the court rulings.

However, notices will inform voters that votes cast for disqualified candidates will not count.

The elections office also said the disqualifications stemmed from the North Miami city clerk's failure to properly qualify the candidates. According to the spokesperson, the clerk did not notify the candidates of mistakes in their qualifying paperwork.

Desulme declined to comment on the city clerk's handling of the qualifying process, although he maintained that the clerk has the authority to determine whether candidates qualify for office.

CBS News Miami made multiple attempts throughout the week, including Friday, to contact the city clerk about the disqualifications and allegations surrounding the qualifying process.

When reached Friday, the clerk responded, "I can't," and declined to comment further.

For voters like Landgrebe, the controversy raises questions about the candidates' ability to follow election rules.

"A candidate that isn't following directions would be a concern anyway," she said.

With Election Day approaching Tuesday, Nov. 3, the ongoing legal challenges could still affect which candidates are eligible to receive votes in North Miami's municipal races.

Editor's note: An earlier version of this story reported that North Miami Mayor Alix Desulme paid his qualifying fees from a personal bank account. Desulme said the fees were paid with a cashier's check funded by his campaign account and that the issue involved the requirement for a campaign account check bearing his treasurer's signature. The story has been updated to reflect his clarification.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue