Charges Dropped In Estes Park Rockfall Death
ESTES PARK, Colo. (CBS4)-- Charges stemming from a teenager's death in Estes Park last summer have been dropped.
Freddie Bailey, 16, was charged with reckless manslaughter.
Prosecutors said he kicked free the rock that tumbled down a hillside and killed Audra Brownell, 17, from Michigan. She was on a church trip to Estes Park June 17, 2010 when she was killed.
Initial reports from witnesses who were with Bailey indicated that he intended the rock to fall from the cliff and into the river below in an attempt to cause others to believe that he had fallen into the river.
According to the Larimer County District Attorney Larry R. Abrahamson, there was no evidence that Bailey intended to cause injury to anyone.
A manslaughter conviction requires a finding of recklessness in Colorado.
The District Attorney filed a motion asking the court to dismiss the delinquency petition against Bailey. Parents of essential juvenile witnesses were concerned with re-traumatizing their children by having them testify about the highly emotional event.
The Larimer County District Attorney also said some of the juvenile witnesses now have different recollections of exactly what was said and what happened July 17, 2010.
The Larimer County District Attorney said evidence does not exist that would allow a jury to find guilt beyond a reasonable doubt and will not proceed with the prosecution.
The trial was scheduled to start Feb. 1.
"We were also quite anxious to show that in part this investigation seems to be designed to shield Estes Park from responsibility for setting a picnic area below a cliff that was a known rock fall zone and remains a risk to citizens and visitors to Estes Park. So all that stuff didn't get presented to a jury, and yet the Baileys are appreciative that they don't have to go through a trial," said Defense Attorney Larry Mertes.
Bailey lives in Texas where he lives with his parents.