Watch CBS News

Legality of Trump's D.C. takeover

CBS News justice correspondent Scott MacFarlane examines the legality behind President Trump's takeover of the Metropolitan Police Department and the deployment of the National Guard to Washington, D.C.
Aug 12, 2025 (02:07)

TRANSCRIPT FOR: “HOW LEGAL IS TRUMP'S FEDERALIZATION OF D.C. POLICE, NATIONAL GUARD DEPLOYMENT?”

EROLL BARNETT:
00:00:00

CBS News Justice Correspondent Scott MacFarlane joins us from Washington with more on all of this. Good morning, Scott. This really is an unprecedented move from any president, so what is the legal justification, and how far could this go as far as other cities? It's noteworthy, Errol, there's been no legal challenge filed by the leaders of the District of Columbia, an indication they think the president is well within his authority to unilaterally call up the DC National Guard, deploy them on the streets in a supportive law-enforcement mission, and to federalize the nearly 4,000-person Metropolitan Police Department in Washington, DC. Because this is the District of Columbia, not a city, not a state, the president has unique powers here. The broader question, though, is what impact is this going to have? We know what it looks like so far. You see federal agents; FBI agents; Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms agents on the street almost side by side or block by block with DC police officers, monitoring for street crimes. The National Guard still has yet to deploy into the district itself, still readying themselves, readying their equipment. We'll expect to see them by week's end. But it's hard to get a gauge, Errol, on what's going to be a determinative success here. What means this worked? Is it a 30-day crime reduction in the data? Is it no friction between the new law enforcement on the ground and the residents of Washington, DC? And can things change in such a short window of time over 30 days? And the mayor is arguing what you see on the screen, that crime is already down significantly from last year, plummeting by more than 25%. That includes robberies. That includes homicides. And she says that's from partnering with the federal government and empowering the local police.

EROLL BARNETT:
00:01:52

Yeah, and as you've been reporting, Scott, many of these federal agents don't have experience, effectively, as foot cops or street cops, going one on one with people, so there's a potential there for friction. We'll continue to watch that closely. Scott, thank you very much.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue