Watch CBS News

Westmoreland Co. Jury Finds Man Who Claims His Twin Brother Was The Shooter Guilty Of Murder

GREENSBURG, Pa. (KDKA) - A jury has reached a verdict in the Westmoreland County murder case of a man who says his twin brother was the real killer.

It took two hours for a jury to find Darrelle Tolbert-McGhee guilty in the shooting death of 33-year-old Michael Wilson in April 2017 in Jeannette.

Tolbert-McGhee's defense attorney Tim Dawson says his client wasn't the shooter. Instead, during the trial he pointed to Tolbert-McGhee's now-dead identical twin brother.

The jury in Westmoreland County reached their verdict shortly after 2 p.m. Friday.

"I told him to expect the worst and the worst arrived," Dawson says.

In his closing argument, Dawson told the jury the surveillance videos show a shooting and the videos certainly cannot identify anybody. He also claims there's no evidence against his client, along with no evidence of a motive.

(Photo Credit: KDKA)
dwayne tolbert-mcghee
(Photo Credit: KDKA)

Assistant District Attorney Peter Caravello countered in his closing saying as for a motive, it may never be known. He went on to say there was physical evidence of bullets and busted glass.

Regarding the mistaken identity claim by the defense, Caravello told the panel it doesn't matter if the two looked alike.


"I give credit to the prosecution they were able to convince the jury that the one identical twin committed the murder rather than the other one," he says.

Convicted of the killing, Tolbert-McGhee faces life in prison.

Stay with KDKA for the latest on this developing story.


View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.