Watch CBS News

2 Phila. Men Freed After Serving 15 Years For Murder Won't Be Retried

By Pat Loeb

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) -- The Philadelphia district attorney has decided not to retry two men who were freed from prison last fall after serving fifteen years for a 1995 murder, after the men's case was championed by the Innocence Project at Temple University.

Eugene Gilyard and Lance Felder were convicted of a brutal robbery and shooting on the strength of a single witness who picked them out of a photo array two years after the crime.

A judge ordered their release last November, describing the evidence as "extremely weak" and ruling that a jury should get a chance to hear the case again because of new evidence uncovered by the Innocence Project.

The DA says the passage of time has made a new case too difficult to prosecute, so the charges against Gilyard and Felder are being dropped.

"They are absolutely thrilled, over-the-moon, and ecstatic," says Marissa Bluestine of the Innocence Project.  She says she would have liked to see the DA pursue the new evidence, which she says pointed to a different suspect, but is pleased that Gilyard and Felder are free.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.