Watch CBS News

Prof. Charges Pentagon Cover-Up

The Pentagon is accused of trying to hush a critic of the national missile defense proposal, a newspaper reports.

The News York Times reported in Friday's editions that MIT professor Theodore Postol claims the Defense Department is punishing him by trying to get university administrators to stop him from distributing a report widely available on the Internet.

The university, which has contracts with the Defense Department, has not taken action against Postol, but correspondence indicates the administrators might eventual do so, despite reservations.

The report concerns another NMD critic, Nira Schwartz, an engineer who used to work for military contractor TRW and has accused the company of faking tests of the system. The Pentagon commissioned the report to evaluate Schwartz's claim, and the final product was critical of her assertions.

Read the Documents
As posted on the Web site of the Federation of American Scientists:
  • The May 11, 2000 letter from Theodore Postol to then-White House chief of staff John Podesta.
  • The report the Pentagon contends is secret.
  • Postol reviewed the report and said its claims were false, which the Pentagon denies. The professor made the claims in a letter to the White House.

    Shortly after that, the Times says, the Pentagon said that classified information remained in the report. It declared Postol's letter secret because it contained that information.

    "Just because it is made public doesn't mean it's declassified," the newspaper quotes Lt. Col. Rick Lehner, a spokesman for the Ballistic Missile Defense Organization, as saying.

    The letter from Postol to then-White House chief of staff John Podesta, posted on the Web site of the Federation of American Scientists, discusses a test of the national missile defense technology.

    "I have obtained and analyzed the Ballistic Missile Defense Organization's (BMDO's) own published data from the Integrated Flight Test –1A (IFT-1A) and have discovered that the BMDO's own data shows that the Exoatmospheric Kill Vehicle (EKV) will be defeated by the simplest of balloon decoys," he wrote. "I also have documentation that shows that the BMDO in coordination wth its contractors attempted to hide this fact by tampering with both the data and analysis from the IFT-1A experiment."

    In an interview with CBS News' 60 Minutes II last December, Postol claimed the whole system currently being tested by the Pentagon is fatally flawed and that the Defense Department and the Justice Department have known that for years.


    Click here to learn more about the world's nuclear arsenals.


    "When I talk fraud, I'm being careful about the use of the word," said Postol. "I'm not saying there are people who have made a mistake, and I disagree with them…I'm saying that there are people who know that this system will not work and are trying to cover it up. That's what I'm saying here. So I am making a serious charge, I know that."

    Earlier this month, in a Pentagon test of the national missile defense technology, an interceptor successfully destroyed a dummy warhead, despite the malfunction of a radar component. The previous two tests were failures.

    ©MMI, CBS Worldwide Inc. All Rights Reserved

    View CBS News In
    CBS News App Open
    Chrome Safari Continue