Indictment issued for Aurora police officer in Rajon Belt-Stubblefield shooting

An Aurora police officer is facing charges in connection with the 2025 fatal shooting of Rajon Belt-Stubblefield after a grand jury returned an indictment in the case. 

Officer Matthew Neely is facing charges of second-degree murder and manslaughter. Neely surrendered over the weekend after an arrest warrant was issued for him. He has been placed on unpaid administrative leave.

The indictment was announced on Monday morning during a news conference with the 18th Judicial District Attorney's Office.  

"After reviewing the evidence presented during the grand jury proceedings, the grand jury determined there was probable cause to support these criminal charges," said Arapahoe County District Attorney Amy Padden. 

Belt-Stubblefield, 37, was shot and killed during an encounter with Aurora police after officers attempted to stop him following a crash. Body camera video released by the Aurora Police Department showed Belt-Stubblefield tossing a handgun before a physical confrontation with the officer moments before the shooting.

In May, the 18th Judicial District Attorney's Office announced it had referred the case to a grand jury to determine whether criminal charges were warranted. 

The shooting drew attention and renewed scrutiny of the Aurora Police Department, which remains under a consent decree requiring reforms to its policing practices.

Neely's lawyer Carrie Slinkard issued this statement after the charges were announced, "We are disappointed by the grand jury's decision to return an indictment against our client. While we respect the legal process, a grand jury proceeding is conducted in secret, and the defense has no opportunity to present evidence, cross-examine witnesses, or challenge the government's presentation. Because this case is now pending before the court, we will not litigate it through the media or comment on specific allegations. We do, however, look forward to presenting the full facts at the appropriate time and remain confident in our client's defense."  

Aurora Police Chief Todd Chamberlain issued this statement to CBS Colorado, "A grand jury convened by the 18th Judicial District Attorney's Office has announced they have returned an indictment related to an officer-involved shooting that occurred last year.  

"The Aurora Police Department respects the judicial process and because this matter is before the courts, it would be inappropriate for me to comment on the merits of this case at this time.
 
"I will say this: police officers are routinely called on to address – sometimes in seconds – dangerous and rapidly evolving situations they did not create. I am confident that all the facts will be fully examined through due process. As with any case, these filing charges are not a determination of guilt.
 
"To the Aurora Police Department: You work tirelessly for this community. Continue to serve with professionalism, compassion and integrity. Know this – I am grateful for every one of you and your efforts to make Aurora a better, safer city."

Neely was released after he posted a $200,000 cash/surety bond. His next court date has been scheduled for Aug. 17.