Last Updated May 24, 2011 11:32 AM EDT
Nice Work if You Can Get It?
Google no doubt would argue that you get what you pay for. Offering tremendous benefits and working conditions is a pretty conventional way of trying to attract the best and the brightest. And if it worked as simply as that, Wall Street might not be so worried.
But here are some of the reasons for concern.
1. Money isn't a great motivator
There's tremendous evidence that high pay isn't correlated with tremendous creativity or indeed productivity. Dan Pink's written about this extensively in his book, DRIVE. Dan Ariely has designed and conducted cool experiments demonstrated that thinking about money all the time actually limits your creativity. Positive psychologists like Martin Seligman and economists like Richard Layard keep proving that money doesn't make people happy either. So at the very least you have to ask: just what does Google think it's getting for its money?
2. Money promotes anti-social tendencies.
More pertinent perhaps, there's a large body of evidence to suggest that money impedes peoples' social motivation. Thinking about money makes people less helpful, less collaborative, less willing to engage socially. You shouldn't be so surprised by this. Money is often a substitute for relationships: if I don't have a date, I can pay an online dating service to fine me one. But with enough friends, I'll never need to employ a decorator, babysitter or mover: my friends will pitch in. And of course if I have a great deal more money than my peers, that can be a social barrier too. The super-rich, often use money specifically as a barrier to keep them away from people; that's part of what the limos and the private jets are for.
For a creative company to develop and sustain a workforce disproportionately overpaid may, therefore, not just be a waste of money but a waste of talent. The truly motivated want other things: adventure, recognition, autonomy. These things are hard for them to find inside a gigantic corporation. Money is no substitute.
Chart courtesy of Silicon Alley Insider