Gagnon, a homicide detective in Seattle, WA., works Cold Cases – cases shelved and forgotten that no one has been able to solve. These are cases with physical evidence, sealed and literally frozen in time, for 10, 20, sometimes 30 years.
"My god, it's a murder, and someone is out walking the street who's a murderer, and you have to take this guy down," says Gagnon.
"We often will read a case file in a cold case again and again. It's more than just a name. It's a person," says Det. Greg Mixsell, who is Gagnon's partner. Together, they make up Seattle's entire Cold Case Squad.
In Seattle, there are more than 300 unsolved murders. Yet in the last three years, the Cold Case Squad has cracked almost 20 of them, a remarkable record.
But now, the squad faces their greatest challenge yet, as they try to solve two of this city's most notorious killings -- beginning with the murder of Mia Zapata. It's a case that's been cold for more than a decade. Correspondent Harold Dow reports.
"Mia Zapata was a 27-year-old up-and-coming rock star who was savagely raped and strangled and left laying in the middle of a street," says Gagnon.
In the early '90s, Zapata, a singer, was in the right place at the right time. Seattle was Ground Zero for "grunge," a new music that was taking the nation by storm, thanks to Kurt Cobain and his band Nirvana, who launched a phenomenon.
"There was a real vibrant music scene here, in all aspects," says Steve Moriarty, the drummer for Mia's band, The Gits. "I just liked the urgency and the honesty of her vocals. Her art and the music were the most important things to her, and everything else, who cares."
"The fact that she could sing those lyrics as passionately as she did and sound good doing it," says veteran music producer Jack Endino. "Here was a band who had a singer who could actually sing."
By 1993, Mia and the Gits were developing quite a following, and with hopes of signing a major record deal, the band was on the verge of stardom.
Mia's father, Dick Zapata, is still amazed by her daughter's artistic talents. "Mia lived in a world of her own," he says. "She would be over in the corner somewhere, or up in her room on her bed, writing in her journals."
Mia grew up in Louisville, Kentucky, where she learned to play guitar and sing. Her parents divorced and her father moved to the Pacific Northwest when she was a child, but saw her frequently. Mia discovered her passion for rock music in college, where she formed the Gits. And when the band moved to Seattle to try to make it big, Mia and her father were reunited.
"We probably became closer," says Dick Zapata. "We really bonded."
In July of 1993, the Gits returned to Seattle after a very successful West Coast concert tour. But Mia was not happy to be home.
"She said for some reason, 'I don't wanna be back in Seattle. I really have a bad feeling here,'" recalls Moriarty. "She was a real intuitive person. Extremely intuitive."
On July 6, Mia was at her favorite bar, the Comet Tavern, hanging out with friends. She left the Comet Tavern shortly after midnight, telling friends she was going to look for her former boyfriend, Robert Jenkins. Just a few hours later, Dick Zapata says he got a call from the coroner's office and was asked to provide a positive identification.
Mia had been raped and strangled to death. Her body left on a deserted street, nearly two miles from the Comet Tavern.
Gagnon and Mixsell had just become homicide detectives the summer that Mia's murder shocked Seattle.
"There was a lot of pressure on detectives to solve this case because of the notoriety of who the victim was," says Gagnon.
Police immediately zeroed in on Mia's circle of friends in Seattle's music community. Seattle detectives did an exhaustive investigation but ultimately came up empty. Weeks turned into months, and months became years, as Mia's murder case went cold.
"I came to accept the fact that it was never going to be solved," says Dick Zapata.
More than 10 years since the Mia's murder, Gagnon and Greg Mixsell are still digging into the case, and taking a very close look at the original investigation.
"They were able to find everything about Mia Zapata, except for an hour and 10 minute period of time, from when she was last seen to when her body was found," says Gagnon. "It grew cold when they ran out of leads. Matter of fact, after quite a bit of time, friends of hers put some money together and hired a private investigator."
Private Investigator Leigh Hearon was hired a few months after Mia was found murdered. Hearon, a classically trained pianist, quickly changed gears and immersed herself in the underbelly of Seattle's grunge music scene.
"I would go to a lot of the concerts and talk to people in the hallways, out in the alleyways. I got to know all the players, I figured out the relationships," says Hearon, who learned that the night Mia was murdered, she left the Comet Tavern around midnight in search of Jenkins, her ex-boyfriend.
Hearon says Mia was actually planning on confronting Hearon, but as it turns out, Jenkins was with another woman that night, and was quickly dismissed by police as a suspect.
"That is where the trail goes cold," says Hearon, who suspects Mia was picked up by someone shortly after 2 a.m. in a car, then beaten, raped and strangled to death. She says the medical examiner believed that Mia would have died from the internal injuries had she not been strangled.
The medical examiner, however, discovered traces of saliva on Mia's breasts, which Hearon says is the only bit of evidence recovered from the scene.
The saliva was swabbed and tested, but yielded no clues to identify Mia's killer. Hearon kept working the case, tracking down every possible suspect.
For four years, Hearon investigated Mia's murder, but she could never crack the case. And that's when Mia's father, Richard Zapata, drew the conclusion "that I could live and die, and this murder could remain unsolved."
For years, Mia's case seemed all but forgotten. But during that decade, forensic science was making stunning technological breakthroughs, and solving cases with smaller and smaller amounts of DNA evidence.
Murder cases that seemed like they would be cold forever, suddenly became hot again. And when Gagnon and Mixsell began to look at Seattle's 300 unsolved homicides, they focused on sex-related murders, because those had the best chance of yielding bodily fluids containing DNA evidence.
In Mia's case, they made an immediate discovery from the only real evidence from the case—that tiny bit of saliva that had been frozen for more than 10 years. But was it enough for DNA?
Gagnon and Mixsell crossed their fingers and gave the swabs to forensic scientist Jodi Sass at the Washington State Crime Lab. After analyzing the saliva, Sass found two distinct strains of DNA.
"I got Mia Zapata's DNA profile along with a foreign male profile," says Sass, who entered that male profile into the FBI's DNA database of nearly 2 million criminals to see if she could find a match.
In December 2002, Sass had a hit – and it was one that baffled everyone. The DNA belonged to Cuban-born fisherman Jesus Mezquia, 48, who was about as far from Seattle as he could be. In fact, Mezquia was living in the Florida Keys. He was married, and spent most of his days fishing.
With the DNA match as their starting point, detectives began to build their case against Mezquia. The detectives' first job was to prove Mezquia had been in Seattle when Mia was murdered. So they combed through arrest records from the early '90s, and through searching traffic citations, were able to verify his location at the time of murder.
"We have him here prior to her death. So there's no doubt in our mind that he was in the area," says Gagnon.
The detectives immediately asked Florida authorities to take Mezquia into custody for questioning, and then flew across the country to confront their suspect. The interrogation would be critical. The Cold Case Squad already had one big clue: Mezquia's DNA on Mia Zapata's body.
But now, would he even admit to knowing Mia? "Usually they'll distance themselves from the victim. They'll tell you I never saw her before in my life," says Gagnon.
The detectives slowly baited the trap and showed Mezquia pictures of five victims whose cases they had been working on. Mezquia denied knowing any of the victims, including Mia. But since Gagnon and Mixsell had DNA proof that clearly contradicted Mezquia's statement, they knew they had their man.
"There's no way that saliva could be where it was and him not have any knowledge of who this lady was," says Gagnon.
Under further questioning, Mezquia began to unravel. Mezquia was arrested on the spot and charged with first-degree murder.
Gagnon called Mia's father to tell him the good news. "I couldn't believe it. I couldn't believe it," says Dick Zapata. "He said, 'Absolutely. It was a million to one shot. It's a miracle. But we think we've got him. He's down in Florida. We're bringing him back.'"