Watch CBS News

Another Putin foe sidelined, this time by Russian court

MOSCOW -- A Russian court on Wednesday found opposition leader Alexei Navalny guilty in the retrial of a 2013 fraud case, which formally disqualifies him as a candidate for president next year.

However, the first time Navalny was convicted, his sentence was suspended and he was allowed to be a candidate for mayor of Moscow. An associate said Navalny will carry on with the presidential campaign he announced in December.

In a webcast hearing in Kirov, a city nearly 500 miles east of Moscow, Judge Alexei Vtyurin found Navalny guilty of embezzling timber worth 16 million rubles ($270,000) and gave him a five-year suspended sentence. The previous guilty verdict was overturned by the European Court of Human Rights which ruled that Russia violated Navalny’s right to a fair trial.

During a break in the proceedings, Navalny told reporters that he and his lawyers were comparing this verdict with the text of the 2013 verdict and found them to be identical.

“You can come over and see that the judge is reading exactly the same text, which says a lot about the whole trial,” Navalny told reporters, adding that even the typos in the names of companies were identical in both rulings.

Prominent Putin opponent fights for his life -- again 02:10

The court’s decision comes as another prominent Russian opposition leader remains hospitalized in Moscow with a mystery illness his wife and associates believe is poisoning. It is the second time Vladimir Kara-Murza has been hospitalized with similar symptoms since 2015.

“I’ve no doubt this was a deliberate poisoning intended to kill,” Kara-Murza’s wife Yevgenia has said.

As CBS News correspondent Elizabeth Palmer reported Tuesday, eight months before he wound up back in a hospital in a medically-induced coma, Kara-Murza said, “those who oppose Vladimir Putin’s regime, risk not only their well-being and their freedom -- they also risk their lives.”

Navalny, the driving force behind massive anti-government protests in Moscow 2011 and 2012, had announced plans to run for office in December and had begun to raise funds.

Navalny’s campaign manager, Leonid Volkov, insisted that the campaign goes on even though the guilty verdict formally bars Navalny from running.

A look inside Russia's anti-American state news service RT 01:53

In a post on Facebook, Volkov said that the Kremlin will ultimately decide whether Navalny will be confirmed as a presidential candidate.

“This is the political decision we need to win by campaigning,” he said.

Another prominent leader of Russia’s beleaguered opposition movement, Boris Nemtsov, who was a close confidant of Kara-Murza’s, was gunned down in broad daylight near the Kremlin in February 2015.

Only one of the five people arrested over that assassination admitted to the murder. Human rights groups said there were clear signs of torture on the alleged killer, suggesting he was coerced into a confession.

Navalny’s plans to run in the 2013 Moscow mayoral election were shattered when the Kirov court found him guilty and sent him to prison. But after he spent a night in jail, the court held an emergency hearing and released Navalny on a suspended sentence.

The unusual move was seen by observers as the Kremlin’s decision to allow him to run against its candidate in the mayoral race in order to make it look more legitimate. Navalny came in second, garnering about a third of the vote.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.