Watch CBSN Live

Murder case dismissed against "Superfly" Snuka in girlfriend's 1983 death

ALLENTOWN, Pa. -- A Pennsylvania judge on Tuesday dismissed the murder case against former pro wrestler Jimmy “Superfly” Snuka in the 1983 death of his girlfriend.

Lehigh County Judge Kelly Banach granted a defense attorney’s motion to end the case during a closed-door hearing, reports the Allentown Morning Call.The judge in June ruled Snuka incompetent to stand trial.

The decision comes a month after Snuka’s lawyer told the court that his 73-year-old client has dementia, is in hospice care in Florida and has six months to live.

In this photo from 2009, Jimmy “Superfly” Snuka steps into the ring to battle WWE Superstar Chris Jericho during WrestleMania 25 at Reliant Stadium in Houston, Texas. Bill Olive / Getty Images

The retired WWE star was charged in 2015 with third-degree murder and involuntary manslaughter in the death of Nancy Argentino, whose body was found more than three decades earlier in their Whitehall Township hotel room.

Prosecutors allege she was beaten, while Snuka has maintained she died from a fall. Authorities reopened the investigation after The Morning Call newspaper raised questions about the case in 2013.

Banach had ruled last summer that Snuka was not competent to stand trial after his attorney argued the ex-athlete suffers from dementia, partly due to the head trauma sustained over a long career in the ring. Prosecutors countered that Snuka’s brain shows normal signs of aging and suggested he might be feigning symptoms.

At a hearing last month to re-evaluate Snuka’s mental fitness, his wife told the judge that the family struggles to keep him from leaving home during bouts of psychosis in which he thinks he’s late for a wrestling match. Banach then took time to review Snuka’s medical records before ruling.

On Tuesday, a spokeswoman for the district attorney’s office said prosecutors are evaluating their options. Snuka’s lawyer Robert Kirwan called the prosecution’s case “doomed from the start,” reports the Morning Call.

“It was time for there to be closure,” Kirwan told the paper after the hearing. “The medical evidence showed that he was not getting better, and in fact he’s getting worse.”

Snuka, a native of Fiji who previously lived in Camden County, New Jersey, was known on the wrestling circuit for diving from the ropes.

View CBS News In