Watch CBSN Live

Drew Peterson Murder Trial: Judge again rebukes prosecutors

Drew Peterson AP Photo/Will County Sheriff's Office

(CBS/AP) JOLIET, Ill. - An judge at former Chicago police officer Drew Peterson's murder trial delivered his strongest rebuke of prosecutors yet on Wednesday after a pathologist spoke about how he crawled into a bathtub as part of his examination into the death of Kathleen Savio, Peterson's third wife.

Prosecutors are trying to prove that Peterson, 58, killed Savio, whose 2004 death was initially ruled accidental. Savio's body was re-examined and her death reclassified as a homicide only after Peterson's fourth wife, Stacy Peterson, disappeared in 2007.

Tellingly, the defense did not react to the prosecutors latest in a series of missteps by asking for a mistrial, as they have done three times in as many weeks. That may suggest that they feel their odds of an acquittal or a hung jury improve at the current trial where prosecutors have made blunder after blunder, repeatedly referencing subjects the judge has told them not to mention.

Dr. Larry Blum, a forensic pathologist, testified Wednesday about reversing the initial finding that Savio died in an accident. Judge Edward Burmila had told prosecutors before Blum took the stand that he could not talk about how he got into the tub where Savio had been found dead years earlier.

When Blum did just that under questioning from Will County State's Attorney James Glasgow, Burmila sent jurors out of the room and took Glasgow to task.

"It does not appear that any orders I have given the state pays attention to," said Burmila, who once lost an election to Glasgow for the state's attorney's job. Burmila ran as a Republican and Glasgow as a Democrat.

Glasgow apologized for not noticing Blum was about to veer into prohibited testimony, telling Burmila that after an hour-and-a-half asking witness questions, "I was getting a little woozy."

Burmila bristled, noting that an assistant prosecutor the day before had said a momentary lapse caused her to ask a question of another witness she had been barred from asking.

"Yesterday it was a brain cramp. Today it's wooziness," Burmila said angrily. "The disrespect to the court is shocking."

Defense attorney Ralph Meczyk encouraged Burmila to throw out all of the testimony from Blum - one of the state's most important witnesses - arguing that prosecutors have continually flouted the judge's rules an then claimed they were innocent mistakes.

"It is slips in the tub and slips in the courtroom," he said, mocking the state's explanations for the errors.

Burmila denied that request and allowed Blum to resume testifying.

Blum testified that there were no edges pronounced enough along Savio's circular tub to cause a 2-inch, straight line gash on the back of her head. The position of her body in the tub and a pattern of bruises also pointed to murder, he said.

The judge has seriously considered defense requests for a mistrial three times in as many weeks.

Even if the current jury were to convict Peterson, the repeated errors made by prosecutors could serve as solid grounds for an appeal.

Peterson has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder in Savio's death. He is also a suspect in Stacy Peterson's disappearance, although he has never been charged in her case. Authorities presume she is dead even though a body has never been found.

Complete coverage of the Drew Peterson case on Crimesider

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.