Watch CBSN Live

Anti-Kerry Film Draws More Fire

Shareholders Tuesday challenged plans by media giant Sinclair Broadcast to air a documentary critical of presidential candidate John Kerry's anti-Vietnam War activities, warning that the controversy surrounding the broadcast may hurt the value of their investment.

New York Comptroller Alan Hevesi sent a letter to Sinclair on behalf of the state's pension fund, which he said owns shares in the broadcasting company. San Diego attorney William S. Lerach also planned a teleconference Tuesday afternoon to "discuss insider self-dealing by officers of Sinclair Broadcasting."

And Media Matters, a media advocacy group announced that it was underwriting the costs of a shareholder action, demanding that Sinclair Broadcast Group, Inc., provide equal time to those with views opposed to the allegations in the documentary.

A spokesman for Sinclair did not immediately answer phone calls from The Associated Press for comment.

The suburban-Baltimore based company has said it plans to air some or all of the documentary "Stolen Honor" this week at various evening hours on all 62 of its stations. Those stations reach up to 25 percent of U.S. TV households, the company says.

Separately, Sinclair's Washington bureau chief, Jon Leiberman, said he was fired for his public criticism of the company's plans to produce the program.

Leiberman, who had said he was uncomfortable with calling the program "news" instead of "commentary," said he was fired by Joseph DeFeo, Sinclair's vice president for news, and "escorted out of the building."

"I was told I violated company policy by divulging information from a staff meeting to The (Baltimore) Sun in this morning's edition," Leiberman said late Monday.

"They're using news to drive their political agenda," says Leiberman. "I don't think it served the public trust."

In the interview published Monday, Leiberman, 29, called the planned Sinclair program "biased political propaganda, with clear intentions to sway the election."

"I really feel like I can sleep at night and I can be OK with my decision" to criticize Sinclair publicly," added Leiberman. "I know I stood up for the principles of objectivity. In journalism, all we have is credibility and objectivity."

The 42-minute documentary features former prisoners of war accusing Kerry, a decorated veteran who took up the anti-war cause upon returning from Vietnam, of prolonging the war and worsening their plight. Sinclair said last week it hadn't been decided how much of the documentary would appear in the completed show.

The Democratic National Committee has filed a complaint with the Federal Election Commission contending that airing the film should be considered an illegal in-kind contribution to the Bush campaign.

Critics have also called for an advertising boycott of the company.

In midday trading Tuesday, Sinclair shares were off another 2 percent, dropping 14 cents to $6.35 a share on the NASDAQ exchange. Sinclair stock dropped about 8 percent on Monday.

In his letter to Sinclair, Hevesi, a Democrat, said the $115 billion New York State Common Retirement Fund holds 256,600 shares of Sinclair Broadcast Group Inc. and questioned the impact of showing "Stolen Honor" on the value of the shares.

Among the questions raised in the letter, a copy of which was provided to The Associated Press: the cost of foregoing an hour of commercial time to show the documentary; how many advertisers have pulled their spots from Sinclair stations and how much that has cost the company; and the impact on ratings.

"Given the stock's already poor performance, it would seem that any bad news would risk reducing investor interest and, thus, risk a lower stock price," the letter reads.

Hevese said only three of the company's directors appear to meet NASDAQ's independence criteria and notes Sinclair shares have dropped from $15.02 in January to below $7, while other stocks in the sector have increased.

"Some critics suggest that Sinclair management is more interested in advancing its partisan political views than in protecting shareholder value. They say Sinclair's partisan agenda also risks alienating viewers, advertisers and regulators," Hevesi wrote.

"By appearing to tie the future prospects of the company so closely to the outcome of a national election, are you adding political risk to the normal economic and business risks that face our company?"

Media Matters said a letter from Glickenhaus & Co., a Wall Street firm with clients who hold stock in Sinclair, was delivered to the Sinclair CEO David D. Smith and the company's board of directors, demanding that they immediately "provide those with views opposed to the allegations in the film an equal opportunity to respond."

Smith and his three brothers are on the board of directors of the company, which they turned into the nation's largest chain of stations after taking over the lone UHF station owned by their father.

Media Matters said it may seek a court order prohibiting the airing of the documentary if an answer was not received by the close of business on Tuesday.

"Our mission is to thwart conservative misinformation in the media and ensure that the media offer the American public fair and balanced access to news and information," Media Matters President and CEO David Brock said. "We determined a stockholder effort is the strongest remaining course of action to force Sinclair to reconsider its decision to air Stolen Honor."

Glickenhaus & Co. General partner Jim Glickenhaus said Sinclair's CEO and directors have a financial obligation to shareholders.

"We are not partisan. We are investors," Glickenhaus said. "Sinclair's decision has caused harm to the value of our investment in Sinclair. We believe Sinclair must give equal time to an opposing point of view. Otherwise the company is placing its future and the value of our investment in jeopardy, by putting the renewal of its FCC licenses at risk, alienating local advertisers, and opening itself up to libel suits against the company."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.