Last Updated Jan 3, 2011 3:23 PM EST
The latest seems to be a books with the word "rape" in the title. Author Kyle Michael Sullivan has two titles, How To Rape a Straight Guy and Rape in Holding Cell 6. According to Amazon, the titles "contain content that is in violation of our content guidelines," a general kiss-of-death phrase meaning that the company will stop selling the titles.
Sullivan responded that the "sex in them is not that much more detailed than what you find in Jackie Collins' and Judith Krantz's novels, all of which can be found in a library," and that neither is pornography, although, apparently, some television reporter had labeled them as such.
Gone is the company's one-time claimed stance to support freedom of expression, as my BNET colleague Lydia Dishman has noted. What becomes bewildering from a business vantage is Amazon's refusal to list clear standards for carrying a book or video. The company has ignored inquiries from authors and reporters to clarify its position. And yet, while it removes some titles, it leaves standing others that seem every bit as potentially offensive, if not far more so.
For example, in December, Amazon removed some incest-themed erotica where the characters were all adults, and yet had another title that apparently involved incest and minor characters. Although that now appears to have been pulled, Incest Stories 3: My Dirty Uncle Marty, which I also noted was available, remains listed.
Although Sullivan's books are no longer available, a number of other rape-fantasy Kindle titles are, including:
And, of course, clear standards are all but impossible to establish in the first place, which is why we keep having these debates.
Apple at least has tried to describe what it will allow and what it won't, and the company has modified its standards at times to make them clearer. Amazon, on the other hand, prefers to operate with compete opacity. So far, it can afford to do so, given the company's current market strength. But there's no guarantee that some combination of Apple, Google (GOOG), Barnes & Noble (BKS) or others won't eventually whittle that lead down, especially as readers shift to ebooks. And if that happens, Amazon's preference for inscrutability could become a liability.
- Readers Shift to Ebooks: Publishers Take to Drink
- Amazon Removes Some Incest Books, Keeps Others, and Still Has Pedophilia for Sale
- Amazon Pulls Incest Book: Can Jeff Bezos Find a Way Out of This Mess?
- Amazon Goes on Pedophilia Scrub, Removes Videos of Nude Young Girls
- Amazon Kills One Pedophilia Book -- but Keeps Another