Watch CBS News

16 Years Later, Family Of Scott Peterson Claims New Evidence Proves Innocence

SACRAMENTO (CBS13— Sixteen years after the Laci Peterson murder case captured national headlines, family members say they have evidence that shows her husband Scott Peterson is innocent. Scott Peterson's sister-in-law, Janey Peterson, made the claims Monday afternoon on the Dr. Phil show. There is no question in Janey's mind that Scott is an innocent man.

"We have the evidence to show that Scott Peterson is innocent." Full story:

Posted by Dr. Phil on Friday, December 14, 2018

To prove it, she points to a mailman and the police department's own timeline for what she calls the truth. Janey even went head to head with former CBS13 reporter Gloria Gomez who exclusively spoke to Scott Peterson about the case.

"He should not be sitting on death row with this many unanswered questions," Janey said.

Steadfast on her defense, Janey told Dr. Phil the family has new evidence that proves he did not kill his pregnant wife Laci and their unborn son Connor.

"There's no time for Scott to commit this crime. Scott has been wrongfully convicted of murdering his wife and son," she said.

Laci Peterson was eight months pregnant when she disappeared on Christmas Eve in 2002.

Child Stops To Look At Makeshift Memorial For Still Missing California Woman
MODESTO, CA - JANUARY 4: A young child stops to look at a makeshift memorial and a missing person's banner offering a half-million dollar reward for the safe return of Laci Peterson at the East La Loma Park January 4, 2003 in Modesto, California. Peterson, who is eight-months pregnant, has been missing since December 24, 2002 when she allegedly took her dog for a walk in the park while her husband was on a fishing trip. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Her body, along with her unborn son, washed ashore in Richmond four months later.

Scott, Laci's husband, was convicted and sentenced to death for the double murders. He currently resides in San Quentin prison on death row.

The infamous case of Scott Peterson. Full story:

Posted by Dr. Phil on Friday, December 14, 2018

Now 16 years later, Janey claims police failed to follow up with 14 witnesses including a mailman who she calls critical to the case.

"The mailman signed an affidavit that said if Mackenzie was inside or out in the yard, he would bark at the mailman. And on December 24th, the mailman came by and Mackenzie was not on the property," Janey said.

Former CBS13 reporter Gloria Gomez interviewed Scott Peterson. Dr. Phil asked Gomez if there was anything odd that stood out to her.

"He was very particular about me taking off my shoes when I first approached the house, so that was odd," Gomez said.

What does a news reporter says about her first meeting with Scott Peterson? Full story:

Posted by Dr. Phil on Friday, December 14, 2018

But Janey claims Gomez's reporting was inaccurate, and coupled with shoddy police work, helped convict Scott in the court of public opinion.

"He's on death row because he asked Gloria Gomez to take her shoes off," Janey said.

Gomez refuted Janey's comments on the show.

"But at the end of the day, that body was discovered where Scott Peterson went fishing. That you cannot deny," Gomez said.

The Peterson family is now pushing for a new trial, and only time will tell if they'll be successful.

When Dr. Phil asked Gomez if she thinks Janey's new evidence creates doubt about who is responsible for the crime, she said, "the jury got it right."

However, a federal prosecutor disagreed.

"The forensics that were presented back at his original trial and what we know about it now, it's a totally different ball game," Mark Godsey claims.

After hearing from people on both sides, about half the audience of the Dr. Phil Show indicated they thought Scott Peterson deserved a new trial.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.