Watch CBS News

Tristin Ensinger, Accused Of Shooting Lincoln County Deputy Michael Hutton, Linked To Ohio Murder Two Days Prior

LINCOLN COUNTY, Colo. (CBS4) - Tristin Ensinger, the suspect accused of shooting a Lincoln County deputy last week before turning the gun on himself, is also linked to a murder in Ohio. The deadly shooting in Beallsville, Ohio happened just two days prior to the shooting in Lincoln County that injured Deputy Michael Hutton.

Tristin Ensinger (Monroe County Sheriff Ohio)
Tristin Ensinger (credit: Monroe County Ohio Sheriff's Office)

The Monroe County Ohio Sheriff's Office was called to the shooting on May 18 at a home on Varner Ridge Road. Detectives said Timothy Frame, 39, was shot multiple times and died from his injuries.

Witnesses told investigators that they saw a man walking near the home before the shooting. While trying to identify the man, the Monroe County Sheriff's Office received a call from the Lincoln County Coroner's Office notifying them of Ensinger's death, because Ensinger was from Ohio.

Ohio detectives called the Lincoln County Sheriff's Office and learned Deputy Hutton responded to a report of a burglary in progress involving a semi when he was ambushed by Ensinger. Investigators say Deputy Hutton returned fire before Ensinger ran into a nearby field and shot himself.

Deputy Michael Hutton
(credit: Lincoln County)

Hutton was shot in the torso and arms multiple times. He was released from the hospital on Tuesday after spending time in the Intensive Care Unit.

Hutton Release Blumer LU8_frame_13670
Michael Hutton (credit: CBS)

"Thank you for all your support, thank you everyone. I got lucky, I got lucky," Hutton said before a motorcade ushered the recovering deputy back to his home in Limon.

(credit: CBS)

Evidence collected from Lincoln County matched evidence from the Ohio homicide, according to officials. Witnesses who saw the man walking down the road from the Ohio homicide also identified the suspect as Ensinger from a photo lineup.

Monroe County detectives flew to Colorado and searched Ensinger's vehicle where they located evidence that they say placed Ensinger at the home where Frame was killed. The motive for the Ohio shooting is still unclear.

Investigators say Tristin suffered from a mental illness and drug abuse. Monroe County Sheriff Charles Black Jr. released the following statement on social media:

"It is a tragic incident; Timothy's life was taken and a Lincoln County Deputy was also shot multiple times. Our prayers go out to all the victims, victims' families, and the suspects family, many lives have been permanently altered due to these tragic events."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.