Watch CBS News

Chicago City Council votes to use $75 million in parking meter funds to help shore up city pensions

The Chicago City Council on Monday overwhelmingly voted to use $75 million from the deal to sell the city's parking meters to a new owner to make an immediate extra payment towards the city's massive pension debt, rather than allow Mayor Brandon Johnson to use the funds to help balance next year's budget.

While the 44-6 vote effectively blows a $75 million hole in the mayor's 2027 budget proposal, alders argued the funds were always intended to continue chipping away at the city's $36 billion pension debt, not to help balance next year's budget.

"For too long, one-off revenues and asset leases have been used to fill immediate short-term budget holes at the expense of our long-term financial health. By passing this ordinance, we are drawing a hard line in the sand, not just for today but for the future of Chicago's fiscal management," said Ald. Pat Dowell (3rd), who chairs the City Council Finance Committee.

Dowell was part of the team of alders who negotiated a deal allowing Chicago's private parking meters to be sold to a new company. Alders voted 46-3 in late September to deal the remaining 57 years of the lease on the city's meters to New York City-based Stonepeak Partners LLC for $2.63 billion. The dried ink came with a perk for taxpayers — a one-time $75 million transfer fee the city will receive.

Supporters of that deal said the $75 million was always intended to be used as an additional pension payment beyond the city's legally mandated annual payments or supplemental pension payments included in the city's annual budgets.

However, after the parking meter transfer was approved, Johnson tried to use the $75 million transfer fee to cover a portion of the $363 million supplemental pension payment in his 2027 budget plan, rather than use it as an immediate additional pension payment, angering Dowell and others on the City Council.

Ald. Bill Conway (34th) reiterated on Monday that the $75 million transfer fee was always intended as an extra pension payment, not to balance the city's 2027 budget.

"It was clear that this $75 million was clearly meant as a onetime little shot in the arm to these pensions, and it was a bit disingenuous to put it in the budget knowing that wasn't the intent," he said.

Ald. Jason Ervin (28th) argued that spending the $75 million transfer fee on an additional pension payment would mean cutting various vital city services, including funding for youth jobs, public libraries, community violence intervention programs, tree trimming, and more.

"We know that these services are needed in these communities," Ervin said. "What sense does this make?"

However, supporters of using the transfer fee to help pay off the city's pension debt will save taxpayers more money in the long-run.

Dowell said the City Council's financial advisers have estimated using the $75 million for an immediate pension payment this year will save taxpayers $213 million in the coming years.

"The intent was to pay an extra extra pension payment, and that's what we are going to do," Dowell said. "The decision to do it in 2026 actually is better for us financially than it is to do in 2027."

Supporters of using the funds for pensions noted the transfer fee is a one-time payment that won't be repeated in future budget years, meaning it can't be counted on to continue paying for city services after 2027.

"We are here to do a responsible thing here today despite being told we're the boogeyman," said Ald. Brendan Reilly (42nd). "This is a good deal for the taxpayers today, and it will be in 10 years from now."

Ald. Monique Scott (24th) noted that the alders who negotiated the parking meter transfer deal never intended the $75 million to be used for funding city services as Johnson wanted to do.

"That $75 million was never in the deal for my community," she said. "This was supposed to go to our pensions. We didn't negotiate it to go to the libraries. We didn't negotiate it to go to any other part of the budget."

Ald. Maria Hadden (49th) said, when it comes to how to address the $75 million hole the move blows in the mayor's budget plan, aldermen can still work together in budget negotiations in the coming weeks to decide how to fund vital city services.

"We can figure this out together," she said.

Dowell also vowed to work with her colleagues on the City Council to balance the 2027 budget without the $75 million parking meter transfer fee.

"For those worried about the hold that this creates in the budget, I stand ready to work with my colleagues to vet and implement any proposal the mayor puts forth to adjust his budget in response," she said.

In a statement after Monday's vote, Johnson's office said his budget proposal "takes a fiscally responsible approach that allows the City to budget for the full $363 million supplemental pension payment in addition to its statutory pension payment."

"Over the past three years, this administration has made more than $1 billion in supplemental pension payments. The FY27 budget includes $2.9 billion in total pension contributions, including $991 million from the City's Corporate Fund. This demonstrates our continued commitment to strengthening our pension systems while maintaining a balanced budget that protects and expands critical services and neighborhood investments.

The ordinance authorizing the $75 million parking meter transfer fee did not establish a separate fund for these proceeds. As a result, the funds were deposited into the City's Corporate Fund. The administration made the fiscally responsible decision to incorporate these proceeds into its supplemental pension payment as part of a balanced budget that also maintains funding for critical services and neighborhood investments. The long-term value of pension payments made today must be weighed against inflation and the needs of our city today. Directing these dollars toward an additional payment comes with a potential trade-off for Chicagoans, putting youth jobs, homelessness services, libraries, community violence intervention programs, and basic neighborhood services at risk.

The Johnson administration will continue fighting to protect them and ensure our neighborhoods receive the resources they need and deserve."

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue