And, now, like in 2005, most Americans are angry about the government's slow response, with 54 percent saying they had strong feelings about the bureaucracy's reaction. Many doubt that Washington could really help them if they were a disaster victim.
Almost two months after the April 20 rig explosion that killed 11 workers and sent plumes of crude into the Gulf, Obama and his administration have struggled to contain the leak and the environmental disaster. So has BP which leased the rig.
The survey found that 52 percent don't approve of Obama's handling of the spill, a significant increase from last month when a big chunk of Americans withheld judgment. A stunning 83 percent disapprove of BP's performance in the aftermath of the explosion that triggered the spill of millions of gallons of crude. That number of Americans disapproving also was a big jump from May.
Back then, people seemed to take a more wait-and-see approach.
The survey comes as the president seeks to show more forceful leadership on the disaster and convince a skeptical public he's up to the task.
Obama's overall job performance rating didn't take a hit; it stayed virtually the same at 50 percent. That's consistent with the public's attitudes throughout his young presidency; people generally like him but don't necessarily agree with his policies.
Disapproval of Obama's handling of the environmental crisis is similar to the percentage of Americans frustrated with Bush's handling of Katrina. In November 2005, two months after the hurricane hit, 53 percent disapproved of Bush's handling of Katrina in an AP-Ipsos poll.
But people also don't have the type of emotional response to the oil disaster as they did to the hurricane; 32 percent say they feel strongly shameful about what has occurred since the rig explosion. That's compared to 40 percent who felt that way after the debilitating hurricane that killed at least 1,800 and left countless others homeless, many of whom were poor and black.
In profound ways, Katrina changed America's faith in government. It deepened the public's distrust of Washington, exposed inequalities and cemented the notion in Americans' minds that the Bush administration was inept; the president's standing never recovered. Obama is trying to prevent his presidency from being defined the same way.
Public attitudes have shifted dramatically as Americans already reeling over a recession and angry at institutions of all types - from corporations to Congress - watched oil continue to gush while both BP and the government struggled to find a solution and clean up the mess.
Far more people are focused on the spill now as oil coats beaches, kills wildlife and cripples the Gulf economy; 87 percent now say the issue is extraordinarily important to them personally, second only to the economy. And far more rate the environment - 72 percent - as very important than did last month.
More than half reported strong feelings of anger over the speed of the government's response, and about a third said they felt a strong degree of shame about what's happening in the Gulf. Nearly a third expressed strong feelings of doubt over whether the government could really help them if they were a disaster victim and more than half doubted that the government's response to the oil spill, thus far, has had any impact.
All that underscores the public's widespread lack of faith in government as well as the task ahead for Obama as he tries to show he's in command of the response. The president was wrapping up aand planned an on the catastrophe later Tuesday. Obama was meeting BP executives at the White House on Wednesday.
His response is all but certain to be a political issue, defining his presidency and, perhaps, affecting this fall's midterm congressional elections if not his likely re-election race in two years.
Nearly three quarters in the poll said they thought the spill will have some impact on their own families in the next year; 63 percent said the country would still be feeling the impact in five years while 40 percent said it would be more like a decade.
The AP-GfK Poll was conducted June 9-14 by GfK Roper Public Affairs & Corporate Communications. It involved interviews on landline and cell phones with 1,044 adults nationwide, and has a margin of sampling error of plus or minus 4.3 percentage points.
More on the Disaster in the Gulf:
Obama Looks to Reassure, Flex Muscle on Spill
Lawmakers Berate Oil Execs over Response Plans
BP Gets OK to Burn Captured Gulf Oil at Sea
Foreign Flagging of Oil Rig Tied to Blast Cause
Gulf Coast Skeptical of Obama's Spill Response
Vulnerable Gulf Species
Oil Drowning Small Businesses