Live

Watch CBSN Live

Gadgets that make your wrist smarter

REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton

If you're looking for a device to track your fitness, alert you to incoming messages and occasionally let you buy stuff with a scan or a tap, there's no shortage of computerized wristwatches to choose from.

Over the past several months, Associated Press technology writer Anick Jesdanun tested numerous smartwatches for iPhones and Android devices, along with fitness trackers that have some smarts. Jesdanun even wore six watches at once during three marathons over the past month, courting both ridicule and some lousy times. (The author blamed the extra weight.)

Smartwatches and fitness trackers are relatively early devices with a lot of growing up still to do. Temper your expectations, and you might be pleasantly surprised. Just don't go in expecting magic, because that's a recipe for disappointment.

Your options will vary depending on whether you use an iPhone or Android, as most of these watches require a companion phone for their smarts. There are also big differences between all-in-one smartwatches and simpler gadgets that primarily track fitness.

​Samsung's Gear S2 (starts at $300)

JOHN MACDOUGALL/AFP/Getty Images

Samsung smartwatches have improved tremendously. Instead of swiping through screen after screen, you now rotate the watch's circular outer ring to select apps or view notifications. The watch faces can display information ranging from stock quotes and headlines to sports scores. Jesdanun tracked some Mets games that way (though the watch doesn't guarantee a win).

The main shortcoming: limited apps. The Gear S2 works with Android phones but doesn't run Android apps, putting it in a kind of limbo. A few apps from big-name partners like Yelp, The Wall Street Journal and Nokia's Here (for maps) are available, and Uber is coming soon. But most apps the author looked for weren't there.

As for exercise, the watch mostly tracks footsteps and heart rate. Its mileage calculation is way off unless you're also carrying a phone with GPS. Alternatively, you could consider the Gear model with both GPS and 3G data for about $50 more, plus an additional $5 or $10 a month for the data plan.

The Gear S2 works with most Android phones, though some features specifically require a Samsung phone.

​Android Wear (starts at $129)

David Becker/Getty Images

Several companies make smartwatches that run Google's Android Wear software. Jesdanun tried the cheapest, Asus's ZenWatch 2, as a starting point. You can pay more for better bands, features such as built-in GPS or sheer luxury -- right up to $1,500 for a model Tag Heuer developed with Intel and Google.

Android Wear has also gotten better. One swipe gets you apps, with recently used ones on top. Swipe again for contacts and again for common tasks. The screen can stay on without draining the battery, something rare in a smartwatch. App selection has also improved; many apps available for the Apple Watch now have Android Wear versions.

Sony's GPS-enabled SmartWatch 3 worked well for Jesdanun while running, but other non-GPS devices, including the ZenWatch, were more frustrating. The main health app, Google Fit, doesn't let you start or stop workouts manually, with or without GPS. It relies on automatic detection and "accused" Jesdanun of walking parts of my marathons, even though he didn't (really!). Several apps offer manual controls, but require built-in GPS or a phone, which can be a pain to carry on a run.

You need an Android phone for full functionality. Android Wear works with the iPhone, but it's handicapped. You don't get turn-by-turn navigation on the watch, for instance, as the author learned the hard way driving to Toronto with a Moto 360.

​Apple Watch (starts at $349)

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Android Wear will work, but Apple Watch is the one you need for full functionality. Apple put a lot of thought into it, with the inclusion of a lefties mode and a passcode in case you leave it on a bathroom sink somewhere.

Apple Watch stands out in fitness. Although the watch doesn't have GPS, it learns your walking and running patterns when you have the phone with you, so it's more accurate than other non-GPS watches when you leave the phone at home.

Apple's smartwatch doesn't just count steps. Instead, it challenges -- or nags -- you to exercise at least 30 minutes a day and to take 12 walk breaks throughout the day. For a perfect score, you also need to burn a certain number of calories -- determined by your age, sex, weight and fitness level. With rival devices, Jesdanun met the default goals easily. With Apple Watch, even an eight-mile morning run wasn't enough.

Apple Watch lacks advanced features found in sport-specific devices. Jesdanun relies on a Garmin running watch during workouts, but Apple Watch nudged the author the rest of the day.

Battery life isn't as good as Samsung and many Android Wear devices, though he made it through the recent marathons with plenty to spare by turning off the heart-rate monitor.

​Microsoft Band 2 and Fitbit Surge ($250 each)

Steve Jennings/Getty Images for Fitbit

These are among the few fitness trackers with built-in GPS and heart-rate monitors. Don't confuse the Surge with cheaper Fitbit models, which mostly track footsteps. The Surge and the Band are limited smartwatches that can, for instance, notify you of new texts or calls. The Band also offers news headlines and a few apps from the likes of Starbucks and Facebook.

But the Band's battery life doesn't cut it for heavy exercise. Jesdanun outlasted the Band for all three 26.2-mile races. Even turning off the screen didn't keep it from dying before the finish, in one case just a third of a mile short. By contrast, the Surge lasted each race with plenty of charge to spare. Under normal use, the Surge lasts up to a week.

Both are solid fitness companions -- at least for shorter workouts, in the case of the Band. But neither is a replacement for a sport-specific device.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.