Watch CBS News

LASD Admits Killing Innocent Man In West Hollywood Shooting

WEST HOLLYWOOD ( — The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department admitted Thursday deputies made a deadly mistake this week when they fatally shot an innocent man.

John Winkler, 30, was killed Monday night after deputies responded to a call of a man with a knife in the 900 block of Palm Avenue. He worked temporarily as a production assistant for the TV show "Tosh.0" on Comedy Central.

Shortly after 9:30 p.m., deputies say two men burst out of an apartment building and ran towards them. The first man who exited was bleeding profusely from the neck. Winkler followed close behind.

The deputies on scene apparently were confused when they saw Winkler "lunging at the back of the fleeing victim," LASD Chief Bill McSweeney told CBS2/KCAL9 reporter Serene Branson.

Deputies shot Winkler four times and the other victim was shot once. Winkler died from his injuries at a hospital. The other victim survived.

Investigators now say Winkler and the man who was bleeding were actually victims of a third man, Alexander McDonald, who lived inside the apartment building.

Winkler, who lived above McDonald, got unwittingly involved in the violence when he came down to visit two friends at McDonald's apartment. The suspect crawled onto his own balcony from outside and held the three men hostage with a butcher knife. Witnesses told deputies McDonald was acting delusional and crazed.

At some point, Winkler and the victim who had been stabbed managed to escape, only to be shot when they exited the building.

The suspect still had the third victim held captive when the shooting occurred.

McDonald is facing charges of murder, torture and attempted murder, McSweeney said.

RELATED STORY: LASD Investigating Deputy-Involved Shooting In West Hollywood

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.