Watch CBS News

2 Cited In Confrontation Outside Courthouse After Hearing For Alleged Martinez BLM Mural Vandals

MARTINEZ (BCN) -- Two people were cited after an argument outside a Martinez courthouse following the first hearing for a couple accused of defacing a Black Lives Matter mural on a Martinez street in July.

The accused vandals, 42-year-old Nicole Claudia Anderson and 53-year-old David Richard Nelson, are scheduled to return to Contra Costa County Superior Court for a jury trial on hate crime and vandalism charges.

Attorneys for Anderson and Nelson made a brief appearance in court Tuesday. Anderson and Nelson were not present at the hearing.

Anderson and Nelson were recorded on video in July while trying to cover the freshly completed mural in front of the Wakefield Taylor Courthouse on Court Street in downtown Martinez.


Racist Couple Defaces Black Lives Matter (BLM) Mural in Martinez CA by Kreamy Kincaid on YouTube

The temporary Black Lives Matter mural in front of the Wakefield Taylor Courthouse was painted after a local resident applied for a permit that was granted by the city.

In that video, Anderson is seen using a paint roller to cross out letters of the mural, saying such a mural "is not happening in my town."

Nelson was standing near Anderson, making a video of her painting over the
mural, saying, "There is no oppression, there is no racism, it's a leftist

The couple appeared soon afterward on a conservative TV host's program,
where they were praised for their actions.

District Attorney Diana Becton's office had charged Anderson and Nelson each with three misdemeanors -- violation of civil rights, vandalism and possession of tools to commit vandalism or graffiti.

Essayli said that, unless the District Attorney's Office drops the charges, he expects a jury trial in January to move ahead. He hopes his clients can get a fair trial.

Essayli, an attorney representing Anderson and Nelson, was hired by the Center for American Liberty, a conservative group that described its mission as fighting "against growing anti-free-speech and anti-civil liberties trends."

Incidents surrounding the mural put Martinez in the national spotlight for a few weeks. A day after the vandalism attack at the same spot next to the mural, a man was arrested for waving a loaded handgun at a mural defender during an argument.

Two days after that, someone painted "White Lives Matter" on another Martinez street. And again, a few days later, a man was seen on security video apparently photographing a car parked downtown exhibiting messages of equality for Black people and women -- and then slashing its tires.

The mural no longer exists, having been paved over as part of a street improvement project a few weeks ago.

Though the hearing itself lasted only a few minutes, a protest outside the Bray courthouse building where Tuesday's hearing took place went on for over an hour, with one defender of the alleged mural defacers squaring off against protesters.

Two people were arrested on suspicion of misdemeanor battery, Martinez police Lt. Mike Estanol said.

About 60 protesters were outside the courthouse when Bilal Essayli, a Newport Beach-based attorney representing Anderson and Nelson, left the courthouse after the hearing and was surrounded by protesters as he tried to address reporters. Essayli eventually evaded protesters by going back into the courthouse, and left the courthouse via a back door.

The protest was organized by Martizians for Black Lives, the group that requested the right to paint the BLM mural in front of the courthouse on July 4.

After Essayli left the area, protesters got into an altercation with a man who was not immediately identified. That man argued with the members of the crowd for over half an hour.

BLM mural vandal court appearance protest
BLM mural vandal court appearance protest (BCN)

"You guys are ruining the country with your liberal lies," the man shouted out at the crowd, using a bullhorn. "You don't support free speech! Why don't you go to China!"

"It was good for protesters to stand in solidarity with Black community members," said Justin Gomez, a Martizians for Black Lives organizer.

As for the counter protester's statements to the crowd, Gomez said, "It's that kind of language that promotes racism."

BLM mural vandal court appearance protest
BLM mural vandal court appearance protest (BCN)

But things got testier after the counter protester appeared to have been pushed backward over a hedge, and later pushed down in the street in front of the courthouse. The counter protester was escorted by Sheriff's deputies to the county jail lobby.

Estanol said one of the protesters was arrested via citizen's arrest for pushing the counter protester to the ground; the counter protester also was arrested, by citizen's arrest, for allegedly spitting on a child at the protest.

Both were processed at the Martinez police station, cited for misdemeanor battery and released, Estanol said.

© Copyright 2020 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Bay City News Service contributed to this report.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.