Watch CBS News

Nola, Alvarado falter, Phillies bats silent in Game 4 loss

Phillies fans disappointed, but determined after Game 4 loss to Astros
Phillies fans disappointed, but determined after Game 4 loss to Astros 01:59

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — Aaron Nola trudged off the mound in Game 4 with both the bases loaded and another disappointing postseason start behind him. Unlike his first faulty World Series start, the Phillies' bats couldn't bail out the righty and rally for a win.

Bryce Harper, Rhys Hoskins and the rest of the Phillies sluggers couldn't even muster a hit against Cristian Javier and three relievers in a 5-0 loss on Wednesday night. The Astros tied the series 2-2.

"We didn't really care that we were no-hit or not," Phillies slugger Nick Castellanos said. "We just wanted baserunners to try and get something going. It's not like we were actively hanging on, trying not to be no-hit. We were still trying to win the game."

It was the second playoff no-hitter in Citizens Bank Park history. The late Phillies ace Roy Halladay no-hit the Reds in the 2010 NLDS.

Nola, who fell to 2-2 in the postseason, failed to pitch out of the fifth inning for the third straight start and didn't perform like the ace expected to lead the top of the rotation.

Once he left, José Alvarado was worse.

The first sign of cracks in the vaunted postseason bullpen came when Alvarado on his first pitch plunked Yordan Alvarez in the rear with the bases loaded. Then the real hits came: Alex Bregman ripped a two-RBI double to right. Kyle Tucker made it 4-0 on a sacrifice fly. Yuli Gurriel poked an RBI single to left past a drawn-in infield and suddenly it was 5-0 in the fifth.

"That's a tough situation to bring him in, but we were just trying to keep the damage to a minimum, I guess," Phillies manager Rob Thomson said. "It just kind of got away from us."

Nola, who became the fourth pitcher to make five starts in a single postseason in franchise history, allowed three runs, seven hits and struck out four in four-plus innings.

"Not the way I wanted it to go," Nola said. "The fifth inning got kind out of hand for me and left Alvarado in a bad spot coming in with the bases loaded and no out. Tough game."

This was a bit of a familiar outcome for the Phillies as five Mets pitchers combined to no-hit the Phillies in a 3-0 win in April.

The Astros took a 5-0 lead for the third time in this series.

The first time, Game 1.

Nola was done in that one after 4 1/3 innings, though he retired the final six batters he faced and left in a tie game after the Phillies rallied from an early 5-0 deficit. They won 6-5.

Philadelphia's bullpen shut down the Astros in Game 1 to aid the comeback. In fact, the relievers had combined to toss 12 2/3 scoreless innings to start the World Series, the longest scoreless streak for a bullpen in a World Series since Toronto in 1992.

The Phillies even juggled their dancing lineup, about anything to shake out of their funk, trading their postseason anthem "Dancing On My Own" for "Dancing In the Dark" in honor of Bruce Springsteen's appearance at Game 4.

Phillies fans that turned Citizens Bank Park into the rowdiest postseason party in all of baseball — and a 6-0 postseason record at home before Wednesday — hit the exits in the eighth inning. Even some of the diehards ran on fumes.

"We just ran into some good pitching," Harper said. "It happens."

The 29-year-old Nola, the seventh overall pick by the Phillies in the 2014 draft, made his playoff debut with 12 2/3 innings without allowing an earned run as Philadelphia swept the NL wild-card round against St. Louis and upset defending World Series champion Atlanta in the Division Series. His 11 2/3 scoreless streak to begin his playoff career is the longest in club history.

Nola, though, struggled in Game 2 of the NL Championship Series, allowing six runs on seven hits over 4 2/3 innings in a loss to San Diego. His older brother, Austin Nola, had a key RBI single off Aaron during that Padres victory.

Thomson said Noah Syndergaard would start Game. 5. Syndergaard pitched three times this postseason — one start — and allowed one run in five innings.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.