Last Updated May 17, 2011 9:42 AM EDT
Wow. And, possibly, what a waste.
A new study, authored by David Zweig of the Rotman School of Management, Catherine Connelly of McMaster University, Jane Webster of Queen's University, and the University of Toronto's John Trougakos, pokes at the phenomenon that has become the elephant in the room for those who specialize in knowledge management: What if employees-those folks with the knowledge-don't want to share? All the IT in the world isn't going to help you there.
"A lot of companies have jumped on the bandwagon of knowledge-sharing," such as spending money on developing knowledge-sharing software, says Professor Zweig. "It was a case of, 'If you build it they will come.' But they didn't come."
How they Hide
In particular, Zweig and his colleagues found that employees have three particular techniques for bucking knowledge management initiatives, all of which the researchers classify as "knowledge hiding":
- Being evasive, or just repeatedly ignoring requests for information
- Rationalized hiding, such as claiming a report is confidential when it really isn't
- Playing dumb, or pretending they don't have the information that is being requested
- They don't trust the other party. They don't believe the information will be used in a way that will help the organization as a whole, or they fear that the information will be used against them-to poach a client, for example.
- The culture of the organization doesn't encourage it. If people who share information aren't rewarded or at least recognized, why would they bother?
- Cut down on email. Instead, encourage trust through more person-to-person contact
- Make positive examples of people who share and who use information well, thereby highlighting examples of trustworthiness
Would you be willing to share hard-won, mission-critical information with a close colleague? With someone in another department? Why or why not?
- How to Get the Most out of Creative People
- This is Why Innovation is Rare at U.S. Companies
- How Much is Superior Service Worth to Customers?
- 10 Most Stressful Jobs of 2011
Kimberly Weisul is a freelance writer, editor and consultant. Follow her on twitter at www.twitter.com/weisul.