Watch CBS News

Judge asks for more details on Trump's clemency for Roger Stone

Trump criticized for Stone commutation
Trump faces bipartisan backlash for Roger Stone commutation 08:13

Washington — A federal judge on Monday demanded more information about President Trump's decision to commute the prison sentence of longtime ally Roger Stone.

U.S. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson ordered that the parties provide her by Tuesday with a copy of the executive order that commuted Stone's sentence. She also asked for clarity about the scope of the clemency, including whether it covers just his prison sentence or also the two-year period of supervised release that was part of his sentence.

Hours after the judge's directive, the Justice Department submitted to the court a two-page order making clear that the clemency extended to both the entirety of Stone's prison sentence and his supervised release.

In the order, also posted on the website of the Justice Department's pardon attorney office, Mr. Trump wrote that justice would not be served were Stone "to remain confined to his home or serve the said sentence, and the safety of the community will not be compromised if he is released from home confinement and clemency is granted."

Mr. Trump commuted Stone's 40-month prison sentence on Friday evening, just days before he was to report to prison in Georgia. The Republican operative was initially set to begin his sentence June 30, but Jackson granted Stone a two-week postponement after he raised concerns about the threat of the coronavirus

Stone was convicted as part of special counsel Robert Mueller's Russia investigation on all seven counts of making false statements, tampering with a witness and obstructing lawmakers who were examining Russian interference in the 2016 election.

The president told reporters on Monday that he was getting "rave reviews" for his action on Stone and restated his position that the Russia investigation "should have never taken place."

Democrats lambasted Mr. Trump's action on behalf of Stone as having undermined the rule of law, while two Republicans condemned the president's move. Senator Mitt Romney of Utah, the only Republican to vote to convict the president during his impeachment trial, called the clemency decision "unprecedented, historic corruption," and Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania said commuting Stone's sentence was a "mistake."

Mueller, who had not spoken publicly about his investigation since he appeared before Congress last year, defended the Stone prosecution in a Washington Post opinion piece in which he said Stone "remains a convicted felon, and rightly so."

In an interview Monday evening on Fox News, Stone, 67, described the criminal investigation and prosecution as the "most horrible experience you can have."

Stone said that while he knew Mr. Trump might "take some shots" for the commutation, "I think most people, most fair-minded people, understand he saved my life and, at least on paper, he gave me a chance to fight for vindication."

Although presidents have broad authority to commute prison sentences and issue pardons, the brief order from Jackson — who presided over Stone's trial last year — made clear that the judge nonetheless sought additional information and clarity about the clemency, including the actual executive order from the White House.

In a separate case, a federal judge has resisted the Justice Department's motion to dismiss its criminal case against Michael Flynn, Trump's first national security adviser, even though Flynn pleaded guilty during Mueller's investigation to lying to the FBI. That request from the government has been tied up in the courts.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.