Does her argument hold water? Not according to the UK's energy secretary Chris Huhne. In Britain a similar discussion is going on over whether environmental red tape puts a brake on economic growth, but Huhne is having none of this argument, insisting recently that deregulation is a terrible idea not only for the environment but also for business. And the UK Guardian is backing him up with an in-depth article that's well worth a read in full. Here's the essence of the pro-regulation argument:
Britain's businesses are not deterred from investing by environmental regulation.... Your freedom to smoke in public places takes away my freedom to avoid cancer. The freedom of a company to do what it will with its wastes takes away my freedom to bring up healthy children or live a long life. We created environmental regulation precisely to arbitrate these conflicts in the general interest.
One of the great accomplishments of the past half century has been to subjugate reckless environmental behaviours to the rule of law.... Real businesses with real customers need government to ensure two things above all with regard to environmental regulation. First, that it be predictable in its development and second, that free riders are prevented from getting unfair advantage. Deregulation defeats both. Huhne's attack on the indiscriminate drive to deregulate the environment is not just good for the environment... it is pretty good for business too.So in essence, stable, predictable environmental regimes make a steady and fair playing field for business, while wild oscillations in policy based on who's in office or public mood add uncertainly and slow investment and growth. Are you buying it?
Also, in other counter-intuitive findings on the relationship between green policies and economic growth, Fast Company recently reported a study out of the University of Massachusetts comparing the economic effects of various infrastructure projects that found building bike lanes and other infrastructure for cyclists, "generate 46 percent more jobs than car-only road projects." Apparently, there are others like it showing green infrastructure projects offer the most bang for your buck when it comes to job creation.
Read More on BNET:
- Is Going Green Bad for the Environment?
- How to Talk About Going Green Without Boring Everyone
- Green Jobs for Newbies, Via Podcast