IRS identity theft plunges as criminals blocked from stealing refunds

WASHINGTON — The number of identity theft victims plunged last year as the IRS made headway combating what has become a multibillion-dollar scam industry that pick-pockets taxpayers’ refunds before they can claim their own tax refunds.

The number of victims dropped by 46 percent, to 376,000, the Internal Revenue Service said. 

The IRS identity theft occurs when criminals use taxpayers’ Social Security numbers and birthdates to fraudulently obtain tax refunds. The IRS stopped nearly 1 million fraudulent refunds from being issued last year, totaling almost $6.6 billion, according to the agency.

“It’s a much more challenging time for the cybercrooks,” said Mark Ciaramitaro, vice president for retail tax products and services at H&R Block. “All of the easy paths have been closed.”

But the tax agency struggled for years to get identity theft under control. Incidents of the crime exploded from 2010 to 2012, and “for a time overwhelmed law enforcement and the IRS,” said John Dalrymple, deputy IRS commissioner for services and enforcement.

It peaked in 2014, when the agency identified more than 766,000 victims. That same year, the IRS blocked 1.8 million in fraudulent refunds from being issued. They totaled $10.8 billion.

“We’ve driven a lot of the fraud out of the system,” Dalrymple said.

The IRS is a popular target for sophisticated identity thieves because the agency issues more than $300 billion in tax refunds each year.

Several years ago, fraud was as simple as using another person’s Social Security number and birthdate to fill out a fake tax return claiming a big refund. If thieves filed the return early in the tax filing season — before the legitimate taxpayer — they could get refunds before the IRS received verifying financial information from employers, banks and brokers.

To make it easier, thieves can get fraudulent refunds on prepaid debit cards that are not linked to bank accounts.

“I think everybody got caught by surprise by how inventive the criminals were here,” Dalrymple said. “I don’t think it was just the IRS. I think in general, the whole idea of identity theft caught everybody by surprise.”

Criminals can steal victims’ personal information from hospitals, doctor’s offices, universities, prisons — any entity that collects Social Security numbers and birthdates.

In 2015, federal authorities broke up a massive identity theft ring in Alabama and Georgia that netted $10 million in fraudulent refunds. Among the victims: Soldiers injured in Afghanistan who were being treated at Fort Benning’s hospital.

Last year, authorities broke up a ring in the District of Columbia that tried to obtain more than $20 million in fraudulent tax refunds. Among the victims: people in assisted living facilities, drug addicts and prison inmates.

In recent years, the IRS has beefed up its computer filters to identity potential fake tax returns. If there are dramatic differences in a taxpayer’s return from year to year, it might get flagged for additional review.

Two years ago, the IRS also teamed up with major tax preparers and state tax agencies to share information and improve security.

Identity theft is “the No. 1 issue that the IRS talks to us about,” said Brian Ashcraft, director of tax compliance at Liberty Tax. “It’s been a huge focus.”

Online tax preparers are working to better confirm the identity of their customers through stronger passwords and by using more than one way to verify them, said Julie Miller of Intuit Inc., which owns Turbo Tax. For example, after online customers enter a password, they might receive a text from the company with an additional code to enter.

Congress has also given the IRS more tools to prevent criminals from getting fraudulent tax refunds.

This year, employers are required to report wage information to the IRS by Jan. 31. In the past, most employers had until the end of March to report wage information, often long after refunds had been issued.

Also, the IRS is now required to hold refunds until Feb. 15 for families claiming the earned income tax credit or the additional child tax credit. These credits are available in the form of payments to people who don’t make enough money to owe any federal income taxes, which makes them attractive to identity thieves.

The new provision, however, delays tax refunds for millions of low-income families and, some taxpayer advocates worry, encourages filers to borrow against their refunds from tax-prep firms that may charge interests rates on the loans.

Tax preparers and the IRS said identity theft is still a major threat as criminals become more sophisticated. To combat it, they regularly share information about new threats and scams, especially during tax season.

“This is not a time to celebrate,” said Ciaramitaro of H&R Block. “It’s not fixed but I think that cooperation has led to measurable improvement.”