Last Updated Jun 21, 2011 3:50 PM EDT
The claim that Facebook is bigger than Google in display advertising is a shock. Any company overtaking Google at anything is unusual. But display -- banner ads, etc. -- is only a small subset of online advertising, which is dominated by search ads. In search, Google remains massively dominant. eMarketer noted separately that Google still represents just under half the entire market for digital advertising:
Google [is] taking nearly 41% of all ad dollars [with] Yahoo! and AOL losing share. Facebook, boosted by display advertising, will get 7% of US online ad spending this year, pushing past Microsoft to become the third-largest ad-selling company in the country.
This growth will mean Google takes more than three in every four search ad dollars spent in the US this year--a proportion that will rise further next year.Facebook's search strategy
So Facebook has a long way to go. Last month, it took the first step on that journey via an ad campaign from Microsoft (MSFT)'s search engine, Bing!, which highlights the way Bing's results are informed by the opinions of your Facebook friends. Microsoft and Facebook have a deal in which Bing serves Facebook's search needs:
The campaign appears to threaten Google because it underlines two theories that people have used to suggest that Google's dominance of the web is vulnerable to the Facebook's momentum:
- Search results informed by the opinions of your Facebook friends might be more relevant than Google's more objective approach to search, which is based on the apparent importance of the content.
- Facebook has highly distinctive data on its users it can use to inform their search results. Google must guess that you're interested in sports from the search terms you type; Facebook knows you're a fan of Liverpool F.C. because you friended the club.
Until recently, Facebook appeared to be struggling to reach maturity in the ad business. Its ad offerings -- mostly display -- were regarded as unremarkable. It had to reach out to Madison Avenue to explain to agencies the type of things that can be done on Facebook. Clients previously grumbled that Facebook was difficult to deal with. Bizarrely, the company is still not interested in mobile advertising.
This week, however, Facebook debuted a new ad vehicle designed by Leo Burnett, in which an advertiser sponsors a conversation-starting question on its fan page and in a regular display ad. If users answer the question, the debate becomes part of their Facebook news feed. (It is only the eighth ad format available on Facebook, remarkably.) Facebook also reportedly has ambitions to become a music server, too, that may compete with Apple (AAPL)'s iTunes, Pandora (P) or Spotify (or simply pit them against each other as apps on Facebook).
Until now, Facebook was merely a cool tool for keeping in touch with other people. Facebook's search results were once laughable compared to Google's. But if Facebook can get its search play right it may be able to leverage its intensely used service to provide users with the kinds of things -- search results and music -- they would normally experience outside Facebook.
In other words, where once Facebook was merely part of our world, Facebook intends to become the world in which we merely exist. Currently, that "universal utility" role is largely performed by Google. It may not be a permanent state of affairs.
- Facebook IPO: Why the Social Network's Revenues Could Be Bigger Than Google's
- How Google Takes 54 Cents From Every Dollar Spent on Web Advertising
- Is Facebook Lowering Its Standards Because It's Desperate for New Ad Dollars?
- Is Facebook Helping Advertisers or Stealing From Them?
- Facebook's Ad Business Enters Its Awkward Adolescence
- 8 Unanswered Questions About Facebook's Finances