Last Updated Apr 22, 2010 11:07 AM EDT
What did we get for our $5,000? Nothing. A few glossy presentations that echoed back what we already knew. Some press releases. But that was it. The truth was that we were far too small a client for them to bother with. Small fledgling companies helped this agency pay the rent, but that was all.
Several years later, I thought I was wiser. I interviewed a wider range of firms and went for a boutique agency to whom we could make a difference. It should have alarmed me that its founder seemed to model himself on Sidney Falco in Sweet Smell of Success, but in fact it was part of the firm's appeal. If PR's a dirty business, I thought, let's hire a street fighter.
This relationship was more fun, but it wasn't any more productive. We got more attention -- but it came from the agency, not the media. We paid a little less and got a little more. But the relationship still didn't deliver.
Over the years, I've talked to many CEOs and Chief Marketing Officers and I've never found one that truly raved about their PR company. The fact that these firms typically have huge overheads -- all those marble and glass lobbies -- means that they take on more business than they can do well. Many are desperately stuck in old media habits (press releases -- in this day and age?) that no longer have impact. And they're all either ignorant or willfully blind to the fact that registering in a mass market requires a very noisy campaign indeed.
So, if PR were my priority today, what would I do?
- Pay for results, not time. One company I know pays for column inches, another by the number of mentions in online and traditional media. This keeps everyone highly focused.
- Use a virtual agency. A newer model for PR and advertising is the virtual agency that coordinates a network of gifted freelancers. With no expensive real estate to cover and no deadbeats, they have to keep busy. They can assign specialists to your needs at a lower project cost or retainer.
- Build awareness through social networks. That way, you're building an asset -- the network -- that you own and whose intelligence you can leverage indefinitely. If you don't know how to do this, send your marketers to some courses.
- Integrate PR into your overall strategy. Don't treat it as an add-on late in the day. If your products or services aren't distinctive, no PR company will save you.