Live

Watch CBSN Live

Who Should Replace Rosie?

Now that Rosie O'Donnell has exited stage left, "The View" has to find someone to fill her seat and somehow match her water-cooler appeal. That won't be easy, but there's a lineup of famous ladies who could make worthy successors.

O'Donnell brought edge and excitement to "The View," lifting ratings and making enemies along the way. But in a move out of line with her fighting persona, she chose to depart the ABC talk show earlier than planned following an on-air confrontation with co-host Elisabeth Hasselbeck.

There's no disputing the star wattage and/or entertainment value of possible replacements Roseanne Barr, Whoopi Goldberg and Bette Midler. Other names that have come up are former talk show host Ricki Lake, comedians Kathy Griffin and Wanda Sykes, Oprah Winfrey's best friend Gayle King and genial actress Sherri Shepherd.

No possible contender is buzzier than Barr, who has said she wants the job. Griffin, whose acid-tongued bark is equal to her bite, would be another good choice, said In Touch magazine executive editor Dan Wakeford.

"She's very similar to Rosie in a lot of ways," Wakeford said. "She elicits strong reactions like Rosie. Love her or hate her, you have a reaction which makes great TV."

In that respect, Griffin — who put it all out there on her Bravo reality show — certainly delivers. But ... can she deliver viewers?

"After dealing with Rosie for a year, Barbara and the producers may prefer someone who's easier to manage and less dramatic," noted Wakefield, who said the less-controversial Shepherd is popular with the show's producers. Still, he said, "the most important thing is ratings."

Pop culture critic Ken Tucker is skeptical such hopefuls can match O'Donnell's TV talents: humor, controversy and "an ability to keep the show moving." The chatfest needs to "look for a different personality" post-Rosie, Tucker said.

He has an idea: Make co-host Joy Behar the moderator and hire the spunky Sykes as a panelist to replace Star Jones (who either quit or was fired last year, depending on whom you believe).

The likeable Behar, who has an eternal expression of bemusement, has "really come into her own in the past few months since Rosie's been on," said Tucker, editor at large for Entertainment Weekly magazine. "She is somebody who could be the moderator and the kind of voice of reason to keep things going when everybody starts talking over each other."

Behar illustrated that talent when she attempted to distract O'Donnell and Hasselbeck during last week's infamous spat, saying: "Who is directing the show? Let's go to a commercial."

Tucker's other favorite is Lauren Graham, who formerly starred on TV's "Gilmore Girls." The brunette beauty is "really smart," he said, and has been out of work — hey now! — since the mother-daughter dramedy closed this year.

As long as we're on the subject, there are others who should get a look. For your consideration:

  • Marie Osmond: The wholesome singer and sister of Donny is now an outspoken mother of eight. She was a surprisingly self-assured and appealing guest co-host a few weeks ago — despite her religious upbringing, no "hot topic" seemed off limits. Osmond, who's got loads of life experience and is divorcing her second husband, could be an unexpected foil for the girlish Hasselbeck.
  • Sharon Osbourne: The wife of Ozzie and mother of three has battled colon cancer, managed her husband's music career and earned TV experience on "America's Got Talent," "The Osbournes" and her own talk show.
  • Kelly Ripa: The adorable sidekick to Regis Philbin has juggled multiple TV gigs at once. What's one more?
  • Mo'Nique: The hilarious host of VH1's "Charm School" tells it like it is. But she's charismatic enough to get her own talk show — without co-hosts.

    Can O'Donnell be equaled? Show creator Walters seems to think so.

    "We've been a hot show for 10 years," she proclaimed Tuesday on her show, "and we'll be a hot show for many years."

  • View CBS News In
    CBS News App Open
    Chrome Safari Continue
    Be the first to know
    Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.