Deep space ballet: 1st ever attempt to land on a comet

A European Space Agency depiction, made in advance, shows an artist's impression of the Philae landing craft approaching the 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko comet, with the Rosetta probe orbiting in the rear.

ESA

Following a precisely plotted trajectory just 14 miles from a slowly tumbling comet, the European Space Agency's Rosetta probe released a small lander early Wednesday for a seven-hour descent to a boulder-strewn surface, the first attempt ever made to land on a frozen remnant of the solar system's birth.

The health of an upward-pointing thruster designed to fire at the moment of touchdown to help prevent the Philae lander from rebounding in the comet's feeble gravity could not be confirmed during final checkout late Tuesday, but mission managers decided to press ahead with the launch anyway, relying on landing leg ice screws and two harpoons to penetrate the frigid soil and lock the spacecraft down.

"The cold gas thruster on top of the lander does not appear to be working so we will have to rely fully on the harpoons at touchdown," Stephen Ulamec, Philae lander manager at the DLR German Aerospace Center, said in a statement. "We'll need some luck not to land on a boulder or a steep slope."

Flight controllers and mission managers react to news from the European Space Agency's Rosetta probe confirming release of the Philae comet lander
Flight controllers and mission managers react to news from the European Space Agency's Rosetta probe confirming release of the Philae comet lander, Nov. 12, 2014.
ESA

Philae was released from Rosetta on schedule at 3:35 a.m. EST (GMT-5). At a distance of 317 million miles from Earth, it took 28 minutes for radio signals confirming separation to reach anxious flight controllers at the European Space Operations Center in Darmstadt, Germany.

"We've been living and flying together for 10 years," said an obviously relieved Andrea Accomazzo, Rosetta spacecraft operations manager. "Now, Philae is on its path down to the comet. We see it in the telemetry."

If all goes well, the lander, moving at a normal walking pace, will hit the surface of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 10:34 a.m., somewhere within a 1,600-foot-wide landing zone. In a gravity field 100,000 times weaker than Earth's, the ice screws on the lander's three legs were expected to penetrate the cold, dusty surface to help prevent the spacecraft from bouncing back into space.

The two downward firing harpoons were designed to provide a firmer grip using the cold gas thruster to offset the impulse of their release. Commands were uplinked to pressurize the thruster system overnight Tuesday, but a sensor that has not been tested since launch in 2004 did not show any change. It was not immediately known whether the sensor was to blame or whether the thruster was, in fact, down for the count.

Losing the thruster "will make the landing even more challenging now because we cannot operate this pressure on the surface to avoid the re-bounce," Ulamec told reporters. "We have to fully rely now on the harpoons."

The European Space Agency's 220-pound Philae lander
The European Space Agency's 220-pound Philae lander, that will attempt to touch down on the nucleus of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko for unprecedented close-range observations.
ESA

During a media update Tuesday, Mark McCaughrean, senior advisor with ESA's Directorate of Science and Robotic Exploration, said the landing entailed considerable risk even if everything was working perfectly.

"You won't gain anything without taking risk. exploration is all about going to the limits, exploring the envelope," he said. "We've been past comets before, but nobody's ever actually dared to stop next to one, orbit around it, and of course naturally, you're going to want to land on it.

"But we know how difficult that is. Everybody's nervous, everybody's on tenterhooks, but we know the risk is worth taking, the rewards are enormous. But we also know we have a mission which is working fantastically and that we'll go into 2015 in great shape to do brilliant science next year as the comet lights up as it gets closer to the sun."

111114landingsite.jpg
The Philae lander was expected to touchdown somewhere within a 1,600-foot-wide landing zone. Engineers said they hoped for a bit of luck avoiding boulders and steep slopes.
ESA

Philae's touchdown, he said, is "part of a fantastic mission" that will continue regardless of the lander's success or failure.

Tipping the scales at just 220 pounds, Philae is equipped with 10 sophisticated instruments and cameras designed to document the spacecraft's approach to the nucleus and collect data about the immediate environment.

Once anchored to the surface, a 360-degree 3D panorama will give scientists a detailed look at the landing site, along with microscope views of the soil directly beneath the lander. A drill will penetrate a foot below the surface to collect pristine material for chemical analysis.

But a major unknown was the nature of the landing site. Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko is a much more challenging body than anyone anticipated when Rosetta was launched in 2004. Pictures taken during Rosetta's approach earlier this year revealed a bizarre nucleus with two bulging lobes connected by a thin neck with steep 500-foot-high cliffs, boulder fields and generally rough terrain.

Philae was not equipped with maneuvering thrusters or any sort of active hazard avoidance system. Flight planners chose the most benign landing site they could find, but there were no guarantees that Philae would avoid landing on a boulder or a steep slope that might prevent a successful touchdown.

"If you decide you're going to land on an object you know nothing about 10 years, 20 years ago, then you run risk," Fred Jansen, the Rosetta mission manager, told reporters Tuesday. "It's not a nice, round potato, it's rough, it's more difficult. But we've analyzed the terrain, we've analyzed the comet, and we're confident that the risks we have are still in the area of 75 percent success."

Putting the landing in perspective, he said Rosetta's observation will amount to about 80 percent of the expected science return for the overall mission while Philae's contribution, if successful, will be about 20 percent.

"Of course, we are here for the landing," he said. "But we shouldn't forget that Rosetta has a mission. It's already done a vast amount of science. ... The landing will be the cherry on the cake, connecting what we see in orbit with what we see on the ground."

Discovered in 1969, 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko circles the sun in an elliptical orbit extending nearly 500 million miles from the sun at its far point -- beyond the orbit of Jupiter -- to a point between the orbits of Earth and Mars some 115 million miles from the sun. The comet measures 2.5 miles across and rotates every 12.4 hours.

Like all comets, 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko is a frozen remnant of the primordial material used to form the sun and planets 4.6 billion years ago.

"When the solar system was forming out of gas and dust, it formed the planets, the one we live on today, it formed asteroids and it formed the comets," said McCaughrean. "And the comets are a remnant, therefore, something we can investigate about the very earliest phases of the evolution and the birth of our own solar system."

The ice found in comets can "give us great clues to the origin not only of our own solar system, but potentially even life," he said. "Because we know that comets also contain organic molecules, the building blocks of even DNA and RNA. We know that there are amino acids in comets, for example. So comets play a key role in our understanding of the cycle of star formation, planet formation, perhaps life formation."

Launched on March 2, 2004, Rosetta had to carry out four planetary flybys, using the gravity of Earth and Mars in repeated passes to pump up the spacecraft's velocity enough to move out into deep space and catch up with 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko.

On the way, Rosetta flew past two asteroids, sending back high-resolution pictures and other observations, and spent two-and-a-half years in electronic hibernation while it closed the gap with its target. On Jan. 20, Rosetta woke itself up for the final leg of its journey, matching 67P's orbit on Aug. 6 and setting the stage for Philae's landing.

  • William Harwood

    Bill Harwood has been covering the U.S. space program full-time since 1984, first as Cape Canaveral bureau chief for United Press International and now as a consultant for CBS News. He covered 129 space shuttle missions, every interplanetary flight since Voyager 2's flyby of Neptune and scores of commercial and military launches. Based at the Kennedy Space Center in Florida, Harwood is a devoted amateur astronomer and co-author of "Comm Check: The Final Flight of Shuttle Columbia."