Watch CBS News

Online doctor reviews not commonly researched by patients

CHICAGO -- If you're researching your next doctor, you might be tempted to search their names online to see what other patients said about them.

However, a new study suggests you might be in the minority. Doctor ratings are less popular than other online consumer reviews of products like toasters, cars and movies.

 The study found most adults hadn't checked online physician reviews -- and most said a conveniently located office and accepting patients' health insurance was more important.

Still, the sites do appear to be swaying opinions. About one-third of patients who viewed online sites sought out or avoided physicians based on their ratings.

“Patients are increasingly turning to online physician ratings, just as they have sought ratings for other products and services,” wrote the study’s authors, led by Dr. David Hanauer, a pediatrician and associate professor at the University of Michigan. “Little is known about the public's awareness and use of online physician ratings, and whether these sites influence decisions about selecting a physician.”

The findings come from a nationally representative Internet-based survey of 2,137 adults, published Feb. 18 in JAMA.

The 2012 survey may overestimate awareness among the general population, since about one in five Americans don't have Internet access. The researchers attempted to compensate for that by providing free Internet-connected computers for consumers without access.

The results suggest that online doctor ratings have gained popularity since earlier surveys. That's a concern since there's no way to know if a review is real or fake, or what might have motivated the reviewer, said Hanauer.

More than one-third of those surveyed had checked out online reviews for movies, restaurants, appliances or electronics, and more than one in four viewed online car ratings. But less than 20 percent said they had viewed online physician ratings.

Consumer reviews of doctors' can be found on dozens of online sites, including some that only rate doctors and others like that cover other goods and services. Most reviewers don't include their full names or remain anonymous.

Some doctors who oppose the idea make their patients sign "gag orders" agreeing not to post comments about them online. Hanauer said he doesn't do that. He added that he hasn't found any reviews of himself online.

The American Medical Association -- the nation's largest physicians' group -- is wary of the sites.

"Anonymous online opinions of physicians should be taken with a grain of salt, and should certainly not be a patient's sole source of information when looking for a new physician," Dr. Ardis Dee Hoven, AMA's president, said in a statement. 

 One physician-blogger told CBS This Morning last January that the bad reviews actually eat at some doctors.

“It’s funny, docs get real upset about these sites,” Dr. Bryan Vartabedian, of the Texas Children's Hospital, told CBS This Morning last year. He was commenting on a 2013 study in the Journal of Urology of 500 physicians that found online physician reviews may be unreliable, since on average, most doctors studied were reviewed fewer than three times.

“In reality, very few patients are actually using them,” he said.

Doctors have even sued patients for leaving bad reviews online.

Hanauer questioned whether doctors should be subject to "crowdsourced" reviews like other commodities. He said doctors risk getting bad reviews for sound medical advice simply because patients don't agree with it. For example, antibiotics only fight bacteria but parents often want pediatricians to prescribe them for kids' colds or other viruses. Doctors' refusals might result in a bad review, but that would be misleading, he said.

Roberta Clarke, a Boston University health care marketing specialist, said there's no reason that doctors shouldn't be the focus of consumer reviews, but that online sites need to do a better job of providing meaningful information.


Digital diagnosis: Is easy access to medical information a good thing? 03:04
 There are no standards, some sites charge a fee to look at doctor reviews, and sites that use stars or checkmarks don't always explain what's being rated, Clarke said.

Oliver Kharraz, founder of said his New York-based site avoids the pitfalls of many by offering more than just reviews. Patients can schedule appointments on the site with doctors who pay to be listed, and only patients who make appointments are allowed to give reviews. Patients also get suggested topics for review including bedside manner and waiting times.

"The review needs to be done right in order for it to make sense," he said.

Lori Goldstein, a beauty salon owner in Chicago's suburbs, said she has used online ratings sites to help find doctors for her mother and herself, and has written bad online reviews for her fathers' doctors because she thinks they give him too many prescriptions.

"I wanted to warn people," she said.

But Goldstein said consumers have to be smart about using online doctor reviews.

"You have to be careful because you can't believe everything," she said.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.