Live

Watch CBSN Live

Mother and son wanted in bizarre Indiana murder plot

NOBLESVILLE, Ind. -- Suburban Indianapolis authorities say a Florida woman and her son are on the run after they failed to appear in court to face charges alleging that they plotted to kill a divorce attorney seeking money from the woman's boyfriend.

Arrest warrants issued Friday in Hamilton Superior Court charge Renee Perillo, 51, of Panama City, Florida, and Richard Perillo, 21, of Laughlin, Nevada, with conspiracy to commit murder, theft, carrying a handgun without a license, possession of paraphernalia, criminal trespass and unauthorized entry of a motor vehicle.

The two had been released on $20,000 bonds May 23 after being arrested on lesser charges the day before outside the Noblesville home of attorney Rebecca Eimerman, who represents the ex-wife of Perillo's boyfriend in a previous divorce settlement.

renee-perillo-richard-perillo.jpg
Renee Perillo and Richard Perillo CBS affiliate WTTV

Eimerman's husband found the mother and son hiding in the trunk of his car on May 22, reports CBS affiliate WTTV. They had been in the vehicle for at least five hours, according to police.

Eimerman was pursuing unpaid settlement money from Perillo's boyfriend, Dr. Arnaldo Trabucco of Fort Mohave, Arizona, on behalf of Trabucco's ex-wife, The Indianapolis Star reported.

Hamilton County Sheriff Mark Bowen told WTTV that deputies are still piecing together the plot.

"The more you hear about it and the more information you learn about it, the more bizarre it gets," Bowen said.

When the Perillos were first discovered by Eimerman's husband, they told deputies that they were homeless and sleeping. They were charged with misdemeanors and posted bond the next day.

"(Their) stories didn't seem to add up. There was a lot of curiosity on our part, but obviously it takes time to run down those leads and put that information together," Bowen said.

After their release from jail, detectives found a stolen car with both Perillos' identification inside. They also found a long list of disturbing items, identified in court documents:

  • Tranquilizer gun with four darts
  • Box of ammunition
  • Two machetes
  • Long-handled shovel with fresh dirt on the blade
  • Blond colored long-hair wig
  • Roll of duct tape
  • Alcohol prep pads and antibacterial wipes
  • Glock .40 caliber magazine fully loaded
  • Commando saw
  • Hammer
  • Multiple pairs of gloves
  • Hypodermic needles
  • Brown walking cane, two men's hats, shirt with a white collar such as would be worn by a priest or clergyman
  • Silicone mask designed to cover the entire head, depicting an elderly man's face/head

Detectives also spoke to inmates at the Hamilton County Jail, who told them Richie Perillo had been "bragging" about the pair's plan.

"Richie advised his mom's husband was getting sued and they came up here to 'do a hit' on the lawyer," a detective wrote in court paperwork.

Perillo told fellow inmates he and his mother hid in the back of the lawyer's car for five hours, but her husband "got in the car instead."

A syringe found on Renee Perillo at the scene was tested and found to contain a drug called succinylcholine. The clear liquid, used by anesthesiologists during surgery, would likely have killed anyone it was administered to, an expert told detectives.

Sheriff Bowen's office issued an arrest warrant for the two and prosecutors charged them with conspiracy to commit murder. With Renee Perillo being from Florida and her son from Nevada, Bowen believes the pair could be anywhere by now.

"We're taking it very seriously and doing everything that we can to get these folks picked up before something happens to somebody else," Bowen said.

Correction: This article has been updated to reflect that Rebecca Eimerman represented the ex-wife of Perillo's boyfriend, not the boyfriend. 

The Perillos were captured in June 2016; the Indianapolis Star reports they pleaded guilty in 2017.

View CBS News In