Watch CBSN Live

Is <I>Too</i> Truthful?

Aimed at one of America's toughest audiences, teen-agers, ads for are purposely provocative. But the Web site, CBS News Correspondent Cynthia Bowers reports, doesn't actually sell anything.

According to Pete Favat, Creative Director of Arnold Communications, "We are trying to un-sell something. We’re trying to convince somebody not to buy something."

The "something" Favat refers to is cigarettes.

The ads avoid preaching, but pull no punches. Teen Erin Stein reacts favorably. "It wasn’t like some commercial that’s like 'smoking's bad for you, blah, blah, blah, blah,'” she says of one ad. It's a version of the truth, however, others find hard to take.

Some TV networks have chosen not to air all of the ads, including one called 'body bag.' In a mock assault, the ad depicts protesters stacking body bags 6 feet high around two sides of Philip Morris headquarters to represent the number of people who die each day from tobacco-related illnesses. is sponsored by a non-profit agency, called the American Legacy Foundation. Ironically, it is the tobacco companies that are footing the bill: its $300 million-a-year budget comes as a result of the 1998 Global Tobacco Settlement.

"I would call it poetic justice," says American Legacy Foundation CEO Cheryl Healton. "I think the ads are very appropriate and they work."

But cigarette makers, who say they agree with the need to cut teen smoking, think some of the ads cross the line. Philip Morris calls them "a step in the wrong direction." Anna Santiago, a teen advisor to, sees the discomfort as a sign of success. "It tells us that our ads are good," she explains. "That they are nervous."

Big tobacco might be worried because a similar campaign in Florida helped cut teen smoking by 25 percent.

Advertising Age analyst Brad Johnson says has simply stolen a page from Madison Avenue's playbook. “Well surprise, surprise, he says, "the anti-smoking people are just as smart as the pro- smoking contingency and are using heavy-handed tactics to un-sell a product.”

School is still out on how effective this bare-knuckled campaign will be nationwide, but hard-to-reach teens appear to be noticing, and that's a big first step.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.