Watch CBS News

House institutes "dynamic scoring" rule for budget analysis

WASHINGTON -- Republicans controlling the House have changed the rules on budget scorekeeping and Democrats are unhappy with the new math.

At issue is so-called dynamic scoring, which factors in the economic effects of legislation when estimating its effect on the deficit.

The rules change promises to make it somewhat easier for Republicans to advance legislation such as an overhaul of the loophole-ridden tax code, since the positive economic effects of such legislation would generate greater tax revenue. That means lawmakers would have to come up with less in offsetting revenues to make up for bold cuts in income tax rates.

The House adopted the rule changes on a nearly party-line vote on Tuesday.

Republicans call it "macroeconomic scoring." The rule would direct congressional scorekeepers to incorporate the macroeconomic effects of major legislation into their official cost estimates.

Democrats say the shift to dynamic scorekeeping will drive up the deficit.

John Boehner welcomes tax reform "conversation" 00:45
Obama: "Definitely a deal to be done" with GOP on tax reform, free trade 02:00

"The bottom line is that this is a way to try to fast-track tax cuts for millionaires and make it look like there are not large costs," said Rep. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, the top Democrat on the Budget Committee.

The rules change comes as Republicans appear likely to replace Congressional Budget Office (CBO) Director Doug Elmendorf, a Democratic appointee, whose term expired last week. Democrats fear that a new GOP appointee to run the agency would be more likely to take liberties with the new scorekeeping mandate to help drive the GOP agenda. There are several competing models for evaluating the economic effects of legislation and estimates can vary widely.

Republicans say that the twin scorekeeping agencies - the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT) focuses on tax legislation while the CBO deals with most everything else - already perform macroeconomic analysis of major bills such as the Senate's 2013 immigration overhaul or the 2010 health care law. The new mandate would incorporate such analysis into official cost estimates of legislation.

The incoming chairman of the House Budget Committee denied that the change amounted to "cooking the books" in favor of tax cuts.

"As history has shown and common sense would lead one to believe, laws passed by Congress can have a broad effect on the nation's economic activity, on job creation and investment decisions," said Rep. Tom Price, R-Georgia, who is replacing Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wisconsin. "What we are saying is let us take what the experts at CBO and JCT can measure about the real­ world impact of policies and incorporate those more realistic assessments into an honest analysis that policymakers can use to make better informed decisions."

Democrats, though, accused Republicans of politicizing the rules to cast their policies in a more favorable light.

"Republicans will be able to hide the true costs of tax cuts behind a debunked mantra that tax cuts pay for themselves," said No. 2 House Democrat Steny Hoyer of Maryland.

Sen. Charles Schumer, D-New York, said in a statement that the new rules "will underestimate the true cost to the middle class of tax breaks for special interests, and underestimate the benefits of job-creating programs that would benefit middle-class families and grow our economy."

"Republicans are trying to rig the rules of the system in favor against the middle class, and they're rigging Congressional rules to help them do it," Schumer said.

"This change is not about more information. This is a requirement that the macroeconomic effects required to be incorporated in these official cost estimates be part of the enforcement of the budget resolution," added Rep. Sander Levin, D-Michigan, the top Democrat on the House Ways and Means Committee, in a floor statement on Tuesday. "Republicans today are extending their embrace of voodoo economics by wrapping their arms around voodoo scorekeeping. They are changing House rules to be able to cook the books to implement their long-held, discredited notion that tax cuts pay for themselves."

In fact, Rules Committee Chairman Pete Sessions, R-Texas, explicitly acknowledged during floor debate that tax cuts do not finance themselves through higher growth, and Republicans said the change is likely to only produce modest changes in cost estimates.

The new scoring approach would only be required for major legislation in which the budgetary effects of legislation - meaning an increase or decrease in revenue, spending or deficits - are at least 0.25 percent of the size of the economy. Had the rule been in effect last year, the threshold would have been $43 billion.

White House budget office director Shaun Donovan wrote a blog post blasting the idea.

"While all budget estimates are uncertain, there is substantially more disagreement among economists and experts about how policy changes affect the macroeconomy than about most other scoring issues," Donovan wrote. "Dynamic scoring can create a bias favoring tax cuts over investments in infrastructure, education and other priorities."

Estimates created under current "static" scoring rules only take into account the direct effects of legislation to government coffers.

"Right now, the House usually uses conventional estimates, which assume that, no matter what the federal government does, the size of the economy will stay exactly the same," says a GOP fact sheet, adding, "But for major legislation, that's not true."

The change to budget analysis rules was included as part of a broader package adopted by the Rules Committee. The package also included provisions to reauthorize the the House's lawsuit against President Obama over unilateral changes to the Affordable Care Act, as well as the House Special Committee investigating the September 2012 terrorist attacks in Benghazi, Libya.

View CBS News In
CBS News App Open
Chrome Safari Continue
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.