At the time, there were a number of immediate analyses of how the content mills fared, with Danny Sullivan at SearchEngineLand providing a roundup. Unfortunately, the initial patterns could have been misleading with only a few days of data available. But it's been a week now, so BNET again worked with Compete.com, which estimates Web traffic in the U.S., for another look at the impact Google's changes may have had.
The data looks at daily metrics for a number of Demand Media's (DMD) sites as well as Helium.com and Examiner.com. Graphs from Compete show two different measurements:
- Reach measures what percentage of all U.S. Internet users visit is given web site.
- Attention measures what percentage of all the time U.S. Internet users collectively spend online and was spent on a given site.
What threw many observers was the bounce upward on February 26th, right after Google put its changes into place on the 24th or 25th. But the view of eHow over a longer period of time showed a general traffic pattern. Looking at the dark blue line, notice that the site's reach dropped further than usual after its high point. Now things are back about to where they were before the change. So, at the moment, eHow seems largely unaffected by the algorithm tweaks. That may be because it focuses on more obscure or specific how-to search queries, and so comes into search results. But the site doesn't seem to have benefited, either.
Livestrong, Answerbag, and Trails maintained their steep drop (click to enlarge):
Demand's typeF, a site associated with supermodel Tyra Banks, typeF.com, struggled separately from Google's changes after its launch in mid-February. But now it seems to be improving (click to enlarge):
Traffic on Demand's Cracked.com humor site also seems independent of the algorithm changes. (I can only guess that the huge spike has something to do with Charlie Sheen jokes.) Golflink is the one Demand site that actually seems to have benefited from the changes (click to enlarge):
With this longer view, non-Demand property Examiner.com seems to have had a problem back in mid-February that has continued. That sounds like a Google algorithm change, although not the content farm one (click to enlarge):
- Demand Media's Traffic Drops, After Google Search Change
- LivingSocial Tries To Learn from Groupon: Some Publicity Really Is Bad
- Demand Media Earnings: Public but Still Playing Shell Games
- 3 Things that Endanger Google's Core Search Business
- NYT: Most HuffPo Blogs Get Zip Traffic and Writers Are Serfs. Glad You Noticed
- No Matter How Much Sausage AOL Grinds, Revenue Growth Will Be Tough